3 ms·
I'm not going to say you're wrong, but I think it's extremely important not to dilute the public response to this. CSAM scanning is arbitrary, opaque and ubiqu
by dijit 5y ago
I'm not going to say you're wrong, but I think it's extremely important not to dilute the public response to this.
CSAM scanning is arbitrary, opaque and ubiquitous. You cannot know what the blocklist contains, such a system is not introspectable and it is not outside the realm of reason that a more totalitarian government could insert a picture of President Xi photoshopped as Winnie the Pooh or the famous Putin in make-up picture: and then they will immediately get a list of all dissidents.
It's absolutely Orwellian, and it's invisible too.
This is not the way.
----
I'll add that in general the hacker community (CCC and ilk) can be a bit more distrustful of authority than perhaps is healthy.
I attended one talk at CCC where a person detailed all the "wrong" ways that the FBI was hacking pedophile sites and collecting personal information on the darkweb.
I openly responded to him in support of the FBI; that wholesale collection of registered accounts on a pedophile website represents probable cause; that if it's illegal to gather information of pedophiles across county or country lines: then we should work on making it legal.
There's a large difference in my mind, between taking conscious action in doing something, such as trying to buy drugs vs submitting yourself for a mandatory drug screening every week.
Here's the talk: https://api.media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8018-law_enforcement_are_hacking_the_planet https://api.media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8018-law_enforcement_are_hac...
- throwmeariver1 5y ago