3 ms·
Is strong AI a function of storage capacity or speed? Yes, absolutely! I actually think the most appropriate benchmark is memory bandwidth, which hasn't been i
by modeless 15y ago
Is strong AI a function of storage capacity or speed?
Yes, absolutely! I actually think the most appropriate benchmark is memory bandwidth, which hasn't been improving as fast as FLOPS or storage capacity. It's not a matter of running a strong AI at 1/100 speed on today's fastest supercomputer. It would be more like 1 billionth or trillionth speed.
The reason for our disappointingly slow progress in AI over the years is that our hardware is still nowhere near powerful enough to usefully implement the same algorithms as the brain, and we likely won't even develop the right algorithms until we have hardware closer to the requirements, so we can test and iterate.
- 0x12 15y ago> It would be more like 1 billionth or trillionth speed. That's a possibility. Now what algorithm do you propose to use?
- modeless 15y agoMy money's on Andrew Ng's deep learning research. Deep learning has already had huge success, both in reproducing the measured behavior of neurons in the brain, and in outperforming the state of the art on various machine learning classification tasks. Here's an overview which references some very impressive results: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AY4ajbu_G3k http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AY4ajbu_G3k
- weaponofchoice 15y agoI'd really appreciate it if you could suggest why we couldn't implement similar algorithms as the brain, that possibly require a massive number of fetches & executions simultaneously (guessing this is where memory bandwidth plays in), but have the results show up much slower. Shouldn't it be possible to have artificial AI mimicking human brain algorithms at 1/100th the speed, where perhaps a single thought based on learned information takes hours, instead of seconds?
- modeless 15y agoYou misunderstand. I'm saying we could, but the slowdown wouldn't be 1/100. It would be more like 1/1 billion. At that speed, it would take years to simulate a second of brain time. Not only would that be useless, it would be impossible to know if you'd actually implemented it right without being able to test it in a reasonable timeframe. That's why we'll only be able to develop brain-like AI once our computers are much faster.
- weaponofchoice 15y agoAppreciate the reply. Seems I did misunderstand. I find it hard to agree, that despite the nanosecond latency times and the terabytes of throughput we can wring out of single computing devices(gpu's etc), we couldn't simulate brain-like AI faster than a billionth of what it should be. You're probably right though.