4 ms·
I am the thing making decisions. To the extent that the thing making decisions didn't exist exactly when and where either I or the neuroscientists thought it wa
by jerf 15y ago
I am the thing making decisions. To the extent that the thing making decisions didn't exist exactly when and where either I or the neuroscientists thought it was, that's merely one in a very long list of things that we were wrong about, and that our definitions were wrong. Declaring that this disproves "free will" is really overdoing it; it's akin to declaring "gravity" disproved after astronomers established that gravity works in space as well as on Earth. Yes, sure, "gravity pre-better-astronomy" was disproved, but that did not cause things to start suddenly floating off the Earth. First you draw a dichotomy where there shouldn't be one, then you demonstrate the dichotomy doesn't exist, then you declare that the whole thing is all wrong; it's just "A -> B, not A, therefore C" when you get down to it.
I am already well aware that the-thing-making-decisions is more than just the conscious mind itself, but while we have the words "subconscious" and "conscious" in reality there's no clean line between the two.
- joeyo 15y ago> I am the thing making decisions. Well if that's your premise, then I think we're already done. If someone makes a decision, but doesn't tell you about it, is it your decision? What if they make a decision and then inform you about it later, is it yours now? Finally, what if they make a decision, tell you about it, and then you actually enact it? Can we even call this yours?
- nooneelse 15y ago>Well if that's your premise, then I think we're already done. Why call one part of my brain me, but not the other part of my brain me? I took jerf's point to be that the part doing the awareness/recording can be different from the part deciding, but that doesn't mean the part deciding isn't me.
- joeyo 15y agoI don't personally think there is a single, unitary self-- a man in the head so to speak. It may be a convenient useful fiction but it probably misleads our intuition on these matters.
- jerf 15y agoYou're injecting the term "someone" as if it has some sort of meaning. What is this "someone" who isn't me? Define it, precisely. How do I determine whether some neuron in my brain is either mine, or this "someone"'s? I'd contend this "someone" is an artifact of your thought processes, not a real thing that you can actually define, and furthermore when neuroscientists disprove the existence of this "someone", it is their own artifact that they are disproving, not anything that corresponded to reality in the first place. This is an interesting result, just as in the gravity example I gave earlier, but it certainly seems to be very common for scientists to get a little too expansive about the artifact they have disproved.