10 ms·
How can Russia pressure and disrupt the process when NATO members are the ones most afraid of Putin? Finland's doing this only because of Russia's actions. I c
by sph 5y ago
How can Russia pressure and disrupt the process when NATO members are the ones most afraid of Putin? Finland's doing this only because of Russia's actions.
I can't imagine anybody vetoing Finland's membership. In fact, the more the merrier^Hstronger.
- mariuolo 5y ago> How can Russia pressure and disrupt the process when NATO members are the ones most afraid of Putin? Hungary is also a NATO member and yet its president (Mr. Orban) has been quite chummy with Putin.
- sph 5y agoFair enough. I must imagine there will be intense pressure from NATO members towards Hungary if they're the only ones protesting. Is there a process for booting a member?
- klausjensen 5y agoHungary has already stated they will not oppose Finland/Sweden NATO membership, so it is not really relevant.
- zsombor 5y agoOrban is the prime minister not the president. As for being chummy no Hungarian prime minister or president current or former has ever served as board member for Gazprom, nor served as head of shareholders for Nordstream AG, or director of the board for Rosneft the Russian oil company. All these positions were/are held by a former german chancellor Gerhard Schröder whom had put Germany onto the path of closing perfectly working nuclear plants and thus leading to the current dependence on Russian oil and gas: https://bigthink.com/pessimists-archive/germany-nuclear-power-russia-putin/ https://bigthink.com/pessimists-archive/germany-nuclear-powe...
- TMWNN 5y agoDon't forget Merkel. There are still people that say that Merkel was always against German dependence on Russian gas but could not do anything about it. For 16 years! There is more "evidence" that Merkel is a long-term Russian intelligence asset, recruited from her youth in East Germany,[1] than that of Trump being the same. One guess on which claim is incessantly repeated by the bien-pensants of the chattering classes. Bonus: Trump and Stoltenberg argue on camera (<https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vpwkdmwui3k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vpwkdmwui3k>). Who turned out to be right? Who turned out to completely, totally, 100% wrong? [1] Something else never talked about is how her parents moved from West to East Germany when she was a baby
- timeon 5y agoYou are trying to shift the blame, but Germany was not blocking the airspace for weapons delivery to Ukraine or blocking the sanctions. Ration of dependence of Germany on Russian Gas/Oil is way lower then ratio in Hungary.
- zsombor 5y agoI'm putting things into perspective. Hungary has 136 km shared border with Ukraine, it also represents only 0.25% of the global GDP, and it is a small country of less than 10 million inhabitants that took in 700'000 Ukrainian refugees. It is okay to disagree with some of their positions, but to put blame one them for the current mess is ridiculous. As for ratio of dependence I have no idea how you did measure it, but it was certainly not per capita gas consumption.
- benjymo 5y agoHungary would be the only I can think of that might veto but they already said they wouldn't.
- greencore 5y agoCurrent Croatia's president Zoran Milanović is planning to veto this. Parliament and PM is against veto.
- jhugo 5y agoSource?
- throwaway894345 5y agoWhat’s his rationale?
- vlvdus 5y agoIt's rather incomprehensible and related to local politics. It's not clear if he can do anything at all so it might be just posturing. https://www.total-croatia-news.com/politics/62559-milanovic-not-able-to-veto-finland-s-and-sweden-s-nato-membership-bids-says-jutarnji-list https://www.total-croatia-news.com/politics/62559-milanovic-...
- b112 5y agoOne of the issues of allowing more and more people into NATO, is that potential for fracturing of the alliance increases. Especially, the original core alliance was very aligned after WWII, politically. However as NATO expands east, the potential for issues down the road grows. Look at the Ukraine. Let's imagine that this horrible war never happened, Russia never attacked, and that the Ukraine would join NATO in 2023. Now fast forward to 2030. Russian political games, and influence, has caused the Ukraine to become more aligned with Russia. What then? Now, the alliance has a detractor of its goals within! And what of other geopolitical issues? Who will be China's best friend, in 2030? With the alliance at its original members, it was more tightly aligned. Now? NATO is becoming far more political. Perhaps this is apparent to many, but I feel this is not as apparent as it should be. For as NATO becomes stronger physically, with more members, it becomes less strong politically/actively. An example. If someone attacked Canada or the UK, the original NATO members would have responded instantly. What about Croatia? Would the response be the same?
- srg0 5y agoTurkey is a NATO member, but it didn't join the international sanctions.
- klausjensen 5y agoNo way would they oppose Finland and Sweden joining.
- srg0 5y agoI hope not. Just saying that their stance towards Russia is ambivalent.
- sph 5y agoThey're certainly not Russia-aligned. They've never liked each other, and Turkey has been crucial in strengthening Ukraine's defense with their Bayraktars.
- Hamuko 5y agoAFAIK, one of the closest calls for an outright NATO-Russia war came when Turkey shot down a Russian fighter jet. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Russian_Sukhoi_Su-24_shootdown https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Russian_Sukhoi_Su-24_shoo...
- jansan 5y agoThey are not aligned, but they deal with the Ukraine conflict in a very pragmatic way. On the one side they are delivering drones to Ukraine, which have proven to be one of the more effective weapons agains the Russian army, on the other hand they will accept Russian tourists into the country this summer. IMHO Erdogan still owes Putin a favor for being tipped off on the 2016 Turkish coup d'état attempt.
- rvba 5y agoDid the coup even exist? It looked like something faked/invented just to get rid of the opposition.
- nonameking2026 5y agoThey can do a lot of things. None which are good for Russia but their leaders might perceive this as a direct threat to their sovereignty and take extreme measures. Either they stop this now or it's all over anyway. This is reckless - we need to start a path of de-escalation - give Putin an offramp. Get to back to calm waters. Then let diplomats do their little dances until there is a hopefully more reasonable people in power on both sides. Nobody wants war.
- baud147258 5y agoIf I were living in Finland, I'd feel safer (against external aggression) if the country was in NATO than if it wasn't.
- logifail 5y ago> If I were living in Finland, I'd feel safer (against external aggression) if the country was in NATO than if it wasn't Finland might feel safer once they're in NATO. The rest of NATO (and non-NATO states in Western Europe), perhaps not quite so much. Surely the risk of NATO being involved in any conflict only increases as NATO grows?
- fsloth 5y ago"Surely the risk of NATO being involved in any conflict only increases as NATO grows?" No, it diminishes. NATO is a defensive alliance. The more members it has with credible military spending (which Finland has) the higher the cost for Russia to invade.
- mach1ne 5y agoI should add that Russia desires the Baltics, which are in an awkward position to defend by NATO. Finland has a strong military and its proximity to those countries makes an incursion somewhat less likely.
- 5y ago
- logifail 5y ago> In fact, the more the merrier^Hstronger Umm ... wasn't that what people thought of the alliances and treaties[0] just before the First World War? [0] https://www.iwm.org.uk/history/what-you-need-to-know-about-pre-first-world-war-alliances https://www.iwm.org.uk/history/what-you-need-to-know-about-p...
- tokai 5y agoAnd they defeated Germany and dismantled the Austro-Hungarian empire. So it worked.
- eigenhombre 5y ago"It worked" is not the phrase that comes to mind when I think of WWI... yes, where was that outcome, but at the cost of tens of millions of deaths[1], years of trench/chemical warfare, exacerbation of the 1918 pandemic. If we could avoid its equivalent in the 21st century, that would be good. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_I https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_I
- juve1996 5y agoSure it's the same if you ignore literally everything else about the two conflicts.
- kibwen 5y agoThe problem in WWI was that alliances were made in secret. A secret defensive pact can't deter anyone. NATO is anything but secret.
- rodgerd 5y agoHe has poured considerable amounts of time and money and other forms of backing into regime change in a number of NATO members; he extensively backed Le Pen and Zemmour, Trump (and enjoys public support from a number of US senators), has close ties to Gerhard Schröder, and of course has extensive networks in the British Conservative Party - sufficient for the current Prime Minister to appoint a Russian as a member of the House of Lords over the objections of British intelligence agencies - and Brexit. It only takes one of those to pay off at the right time.
- ck425 5y agoI can't speak about other countries but the idea that Russia could use its influence to convince the UK to veto Finland or Sweden's entry into NATO is absurd. The Conservatives may have been happy to take russian money before the invasion but it would be hard to do so now and political suicide to be seen as bowing to russian political interests.
- reducesuffering 5y agoYep. Anyone doubting that Putin actively funds and influences right wing politicians in the West needs only to look at Putin's state spokesman, Dmitri Peskov's daughter, Elizaveta, is an assistant to far-right French politician Aymeric Chauprade, a French Member of the European Parliament.
- DocTomoe 5y agoNATO won't accept members that are entangled in regional conflicts which may turn into wars soon (that's why Ukraine couldn't apply anymore after 2014). So Russia's solution would be to start such a conflict, sooner rather than later.
- denton-scratch 5y agoI think that NATO can't accept new members that are not in control of their own borders; the moment such a new member accedes, NATO would find itself in a state of war.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- adrr 5y agoUS said they protect countries who apply for NATO. So attacking Sweden or Finland would bring the US into the conflict. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-05-05/u-s-gives-sweden-and-finland-security-promises-on-road-to-nato https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-05-05/u-s-gives...
- DocTomoe 5y agoWould I, as a Finnish or Swedish lawmaker, trust that promise? The US has not won a war in eighty years, and their shoot first, ask questions later approach may ultimately be more destructive than Russians could ever be.