3 ms·
Why would it be difficult to enforce? >In addition to other damages, the PRA authorizes statutory damages of $1k per violation, capped at $100k per account hol
by colechristensen 5y ago
Why would it be difficult to enforce?
>In addition to other damages, the PRA authorizes statutory damages of $1k per violation, capped at $100k per account holder per calendar year.
There are 1.3 million under 18 in MN, some percentage of those have social media accounts, let's just guess 500k, so a maximum statutory fine for non-compliance of $50 billion per year per social network. All sorts of ways to adjust that down but still a substantial motivation to turn on the "chronological only in Minnesota" feature. Or are you assuming a state court can't fine a social network?
It makes me wish Republicans were a little more sane so I could justify voting for some of them in Minnesota.
- filoleg 5y ago> Or are you assuming a state court can't fine a social network? Social network: ok, we are blocking users from that jurisdiction from being able to access our product to comply with recently instated state legislation, please don't use a VPN to do so wink wink. Plenty of people (yes, even those who aren't the most technologically advanced average users) have been using VPNs for a similar purpose to access Netflix shows available in other regions since a long time ago, so I can easily imagine people doing the same to access TikTok. See the existing "you gotta be 13 or older to create an account" registration requirement on many platforms, which exists to comply with the law. Sure, it is enforceable in a sense that the government can go after any company that explicitly allows kids under 13 to register and flaunts this law. But it is utterly unenforceable in practice, because what is the government gonna do about kids lying about their age when creating an account? Nothing, aside from legally mandating identity verification and linking it to every account you create. But that's not the route I would ever want the world to take, not even mentioning that there will be ways around that too anyway (and the potential side effects of such id-linking mandate would be much more disastrous than the original problem).
- colechristensen 5y agoYou're imagining that a social network would be willing to geofence off an entire state in order to not comply with a fairly straightforward to implement regulation. Doesn't sound like something which would be honoring the fiduciary duty to investors required by leadership, leaving all that money on the table, or something that wouldn't be worth the calculus of cutting off an entire state to avoid losing a portion of revenue for part of the population.
- filoleg 5y ago> You're imagining that a social network would be willing to geofence off an entire state in order to not comply with a fairly straightforward to implement regulation. I mean, the company can comply, and users can go around those restrictions by lying to the company. Whether the company decides to geofence or comply, it doesn't affect how enforceable this specific law would be at all. Users can go around it with equal ease in either case (as long as real identity verification for online accounts doesn't enter the equation).
- kristopolous 5y agobecause it's general enough that it can be challenged. I have an amazon profile. The reviews are user generated. They certainly rank popularity into categories. In fact, I also have a wikipedia user profile as well and there's talk pages and here's the trending topics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Top_25_Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Top_25_Report Same goes with youtube, twitch, imdb, discogs, substack, medium, and oh yes, video games. Lots of UGC video games. Social media can be bad, toxic, unhealthy, lead to suicide and depression among youth, ok. That's certainly terrible but you get a bunch of snazzy lawyers for billion dollar companies that work for the bottom line in the room, this thing won't stand. Instead what might work better is to extend liability law to such forums of persuasion. It the parents of a dead kid have grounds to sue Facebook and Facebook knows it, they'll pull back quick. It's a page from the Ralph Nader playbook
- colechristensen 5y agoOn what grounds could it be challenged?
- kristopolous 5y agoIt'd have to be demonstrated. There's always places to hide in generalities. Every word can be quibbled over as not actually applying and thus sitting outside the definition. It's a prohibition against a generally described feature which makes it fundamentally contestable. And say you nab them. Then they just have to do an otherwise meaningless permutation to the feature and claim they're compliant and you're back in court. Ianal btw
- Kim_Bruning 5y agoHrrrm, you're not wrong. I don't think the law is intended to target wikipedia or imdb as such. Some of the others might actually be intentional though.