5 ms·
As an immigrant to the US, I hate the double standards applied to Americans. Oh, you think Americans are racist for wanting to restrict immigration? How would p
by rayiner 5y ago
As an immigrant to the US, I hate the double standards applied to Americans. Oh, you think Americans are racist for wanting to restrict immigration? How would people in India react to massive immigration from Africa?
- random314 5y agoLots of loaded statements here. Immigrant describes his immigration situation. Your response 1. How dare you complain 2. I am going to pretend you called Americans racist. (Wattabout Indians being racist) You or your parents being immigrants is no excuse for your crude behavior.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rajup 5y agoDouble standards or higher standards? I'm pretty sure people in India would react horribly to such a hypothetical situation. But if that's the standard you want to hold Americans and the American government to that's fine but perhaps then the USA should stop preaching to the world and exporting its "values" and "freedoms" and taking the moral high ground in pretty much every conflict around the world.
- rayiner 5y ago> perhaps then the USA should stop preaching to the world and exporting its "values" and "freedoms" and taking the moral high ground in pretty much every conflict around the world. As a Gore/Kerry supporter I agree. And I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but there’s been a broad repudiation of George W. Bush’s vision for an evangelical role for America in spreading democracy among his own party. I think Americans have many great virtues. But they’re not aliens, and America isn’t a science experiment. I don’t begrudge any American who wants a country of their own, just like Indians and Bangladeshis do.
- random314 5y ago> I don’t begrudge any American who wants a country of their own, just like Indians and Bangladeshis do. Setting aside the fact that your reply had no relevance to OPs argument, I have other questions. Do you consider your presence in this country impugning on an Americans desire to have a country of their own? Just like Bangladeshis do? Perhaps there is a more appropriate country on this planet that you should call as a country of your own. Why are you treating America as some kind of science experiment? This clayton bigsby schtick is only funny the first time around.
- rayiner 5y ago> Do you consider your presence in this country impugning on an Americans desire to have a country of their own? Just like Bangladeshis do? Of course! My presence changes the country, because I can’t help but bring my foreign values and beliefs with me. People who were already here; and maybe like things the way they were, are entitled to not like those changes. People back in Bangladesh would certainly complain if my wife’s family headed over there and brought with them all their individualism, social liberalism, notions of gun rights, antipathy to social hierarchy, etc! Different societies around the world are different, and in particular the differences between immigrants and native born go much more than skin deep, because even the ones born here are typically raised and socialized by parents who come from a different culture. Under international law, distinct peoples are entitled to say “I want a country for people who look like me and have my culture and speak my language.” My home country of Bangladesh exists because of that principle, as do many other countries. Why should I begrudge those Americans who feel the same way? > Perhaps there is a more appropriate country on this planet that you should call as a country of your own. As an ethnic Bangladeshi my kids and I have a right of return. I can obtain Bangladeshi citizenship any time I want. > Why are you treating America as some kind of science experiment? I try not to! My family was invited here by Americans on certain terms, and nobody has ever really complained. But I think they have every right to complain if they wanted. > This clayton bigsby schtick is only funny the first time around. I point out that I hold Americans to the same standard as people from my own country, and you respond by accusing me of self hatred? I hope you realize how incredibly racist that is.
- 5y ago
- passivate 5y agoThe US is hypocritical (most countries are) and meddles with the internal affairs of other countries. Expecting the world to care about US sovereignty is only going to get a few chuckles, nothing more. Certainly no country is in the position to go to war with the US, so we can be thankful for that. >Oh, you think Americans are racist for wanting to restrict immigration? How would people in India react to massive immigration from Africa? It's my view that people, in any country, should seize political power to fight for and implement changes they wish to in a legal, peaceful and non-violent manner. Whether it's about healthcare/internal policies/laws/immigration/foreign policy or whatever. If legal immigrants wish to fight for changes to the immigration system, then they should use all the legal rights they are afforded to under the current law. The previous arcs of history are all irrelevant, people should use the power they have in the here and now.