3 ms·
> What it shows is that the Median Democrat stayed exactly the same during 1998-2011, while the Median Republican moved right the whole period of 2004-2011. No
by Izkata 5y ago
> What it shows is that the Median Democrat stayed exactly the same during 1998-2011, while the Median Republican moved right the whole period of 2004-2011.
Now try doing the whole span it's depicting, instead of picking the best years for your viewpoint.
> Anyway, this story is from 2014, so it's missing the last 8 years.
Here's an update that includes 2015 and 2017: https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/interactives/political-polarization-1994-2017/ https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/interactives/political-...
It continues the same trend of median Republican barely moving while come 2017 median Democrat flies off even further left.
- lapcat 5y ago> Now try doing the whole span it's depicting, instead of picking the best years for your viewpoint. What do you think is my viewpoint? During 1994-1997, both parties were moving left. And during 2012-2014 they were moving in opposite directions. I focused on the period of 1998-2011 because that seemed to be when there was the biggest difference in behavior between the 2 parties. The claim of incomingpain was that "the democrats moved far left creating the polarization". But this is not supported by the given data. The parties were moving in lockstep prior to 1998, and the Democrats didn't move at all for many years after 1998. It seems difficult to argue that the polarization was created in 2017, given the data from 1998-2011. Anyway, incomingpain, the one who made the claim, was also the one who linked to the pre-2015 data. Here's the funny thing: incomingpain said "The republicans clearly moved left and it was the right thing to do." And Republicans did indeed move left 1994-2003... but then they moved back right starting in 2004. They moved right at the same time that Democrats were staying the same. So shouldn't incomingpain argue that backtracking was the wrong thing to do, if moving left was the right thing to do?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]