2 ms·
> The original claim was that the left hadn't moved. The response was "prove it". No, the original claim was actually this: "political animosity may be based p
by lapcat 5y ago
> The original claim was that the left hadn't moved. The response was "prove it".
No, the original claim was actually this: "political animosity may be based particularly on partisans’ overestimation of the prevalence of extreme, egregious views held by only a minority of opponents but imagined to be widespread."
The counterclaim was: "There's objective measurements that the democrats moved far left creating the polarization."
My suggestion was that this counterclaim seems to be exhibiting the same fallacy discussed in the paper.
Both the Democratic and Republican parties are very large, and its members have a wide variety of views. If you pay close attention, you'll see that there's quite a bit of infighting, sometimes very bitter, even within each party. Broad generalizations about Democrats or "the left" — and likewise about Republicans or "the right" — are often going to be grossly inaccurate. You can't just treat huge groups as uniform when they're demonstrably not uniform.
The American people — well over 300 million of them — have diverse political views. But we have a political duopoly. Which means that these diverse views held by Americans have to somehow fit mostly within these 2 parties. It's a mistake to overgeneralize about political parties and similar groups.
I personally find the terms "left", "right", "liberal", "conservative" to be practically meaningless. They've lost all of their original meaning and become opaque cudgels for the political parties to pretend they have some kind of coherent ideology. But this is a bit of a tangent.
Anyway, I would bet that most Democrats and most Republicans don't even know WTF CRT is. Even the ones who complain about it!