3 ms·
That sounds suspicious to me. In UK at least client money should be segregated especially in the context of custody assets. Really shouldn't enter the same poo
by Havoc 5y ago
That sounds suspicious to me.
In UK at least client money should be segregated especially in the context of custody assets. Really shouldn't enter the same pool of assets as Coinbase's office chairs in case of liquidation
- smcl 5y agoDidn't it take a fairly long while before client money laws came in even in traditional banking? I don't have a date so I could be wrong, but taking the history of british banking I have a feeling this was a relatively recent thing. Being generous, we're still within the first decade of crypto as an investment instrument, I imagine regulations haven't quite caught up so really it's no surprise newer crypto companies like Coinbase aren't particularly serious about keeping client money/assets separate. And as much as client money should be segregated, some big names are still getting dinged with CASS breaches - Charles Schwab in 2020, for example.
- Havoc 5y agoMost things should have pretty good client money coverage now - basically anything that is deposit taking and then some. >it's no surprise newer crypto companies like Coinbase aren't particularly serious about keeping client money/assets separate. I'd say the opposite. As crypto company I'd be expecting the regulator to be on my ass from day 1 above the pettiest things.
- smcl 5y agoI sincerely believe that you, the user Havoc, are a responsible, sensible person who would handle client money as if you were operating a well-regulated financial services firm, even if such regulations weren't in place. However companies are not necessarily built that way - if they don't have to do follow some rule that could be considered a bit burdensome and (arguably?) not applicable to them, they likely won't. Why follow rules that might not apply to you, given that you are using a new-and-exciting instrument that you could credibly argue fall outside any existing regulations (and if doing so could permit you to speculate and make a bit of extra money)?
- nabla9 5y ago>In UK at least client money As I understand it, English law custody model is a trust arrangement and pure delegate custodian should be safe in the case of bankruptcy. Shouldn't does not mean that it does not happen in the UK too. The Lehman Client Money Litigation in the UK is a good example. Lehman Brothers International fell short $2.6 billion in client money under CASS 7 (statutory trust, segregation and pooling). Coinbase is not operating with that model. Coninbase customers can be just general unsecured creditors > because custodially held crypto assets may be considered to be the property of a bankruptcy estate, in the event of a bankruptcy, the crypto assets we hold in custody on behalf of our customers could be subject to bankruptcy proceedings and such customers could be treated as our general unsecured creditors
- mellavora 5y agoYes, that is how it would work if Coinbase was regulated as a custodian. Have you confirmed that they are indeed classified in this way, and that your crypo holdings are indeed covered by that classification? Or are you duck-typing Coinbase as a securities/brokerage firm based only on "look" and "quack"? (where "look" was a quick look without going into the difference between crypto assets and regulated securities issued by a regulated public company)