4 ms·
If they have a short position doesn't that mean they are financially motivated to see them fail? Doesn't sound like a neutral source.
by bawolff 5y ago
If they have a short position doesn't that mean they are financially motivated to see them fail? Doesn't sound like a neutral source.
- sanxiyn 5y agoYes, they are talking their book. That's why you should decide for yourself.
- lagadu 5y agoI see it as a bit of a chicken and egg situation: you see a company you believe is overvalued, therefore you short it. The problem is that once you do that you become financially motivated to see them fail, even if that wasn't true when you originally shorted them.
- Pyramus 5y agoI agree with the bias, still there isn't a chicken and egg problem in most cases: You do the research before you take the short position, you only publish the research afterwards. If you are a credible investor, the short position follows from the research, not the other way around.
- OJFord 5y agoAlternatively, 'their money is where their mouth is'.
- rocqua 5y agoThey are a serial short seller. That means they need to retain credibility with their reports to keep their business going. That, combined with general skepticism and a fully-disclosed short position, I think should make it quite easy to fairly evaluate their short-report.
- awestroke 5y agoWhy would they need to retain credibility?
- newsclues 5y agoShorts are their business, if they want to continue to have other investors believe and follow their reports, the reports must be accurate. They are in the prediction (down) business.
- ricardobeat 5y agoThat’s a very generous assessment. You could also consider them to be in the propaganda business, where the mere act of publishing a negative report is more important than the correctness of what’s inside. The latter doesn’t affect their outcomes if the market has already being influenced by the news. As evidenced by the comment that originated this thread, and currently sits at #1 in this discussion.
- Pyramus 5y agoYou misunderstood parent's point. If you are a serial short seller, you can do "false propaganda" at most once. You can still get things wrong, but you are negatively incentivised to do so because of reputation effects.
- ricardobeat 5y agoI didn't say the report can be false. It just needs to be credible enough to raise the question, mainly to a journalist writing a short article on a 2-hour deadline. The report being challenged by the 1 in 10000 people who actually read it is mostly inconsequential after publishing, when talking about retail investors. Any claims of correctness / moral righteousness when it comes to short-seller reports, in either direction, will always be fuzzy. It's impossible to avoid the inherent conflict of interest.
- 5y ago
- FabHK 5y agoStill a good counterbalance to the company and its investors, who are similarly not a neutral source.
- MrMan 5y agothey only get rewarded for being right, and even then sometimes no reward. short sellers are the investigative journalists of finance