3 ms·
Hypothesis: Google data indicates that pseudonymous users make a net-negative contribution to the quality of an online community (c.f. The WELL). They want a re
by jdietrich 15y ago
Hypothesis: Google data indicates that pseudonymous users make a net-negative contribution to the quality of an online community (c.f. The WELL). They want a real name not for any commercial reason, but to hold users accountable for their behaviour. Google's real names policy for G+ isn't part of some complex conspiracy, but in fact standard Google practice - following the data, even when the data contradicts what users say they want.
Is it evil to put the interests of the entire network above the interests of a small minority? If you can say for sure, you're either an ideologue or you've solved the most fundamental problem of politics.
Personally, I think there's room on the spectrum for a variety of standards of identity. At one end there's 4chan, at the other carefully-vetted private communities. In the middle you've got sites that require a "real" e-mail address, or Something Awful charging $10 to join. Google's real names policy is distinctly flawed in execution, I think largely as a result of scale, but I don't think it's a fundamentally bad idea and certainly not categorically evil.
- mapgrep 15y agoNo need to hypothesize, Google has spoken on this. Chairman Eric Schmidt: "If we knew that it was a real person, then we could sort of hold them accountable, we could check them, we could give them things, we could you know bill them, you know we could have credit cards and so forth." http://gigaom.com/2011/08/29/its-official-google-wants-to-own-your-online-identity/ http://gigaom.com/2011/08/29/its-official-google-wants-to-ow...
- ethank 15y agoI think the biggest problem for me is the assumption that there needs to exist a mapping between First/Last name and identity. Its the abutment of two constructs made arbitrary by the media (names and physical self), with the assumption that what emerges is more "real" and thus more consequential to the agent driving it. It's complete bullshit and flies in the face of history, not just what is "right."
- vidarh 15y agoTo take an example from "history". Ask a random person on the street who Ioseb Besarionis dze Jughashvili, and most of them will be completely clueless. Ask them who Stalin was, and they'll at least have a rough idea...
- nooneelse 15y agoTotally off topic, maybe. Examples like yours are used, I've noticed, a great deal in the history lessons of James Burke (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Burke_%28science_historian%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Burke_%28science_historia...). He regularly describes what someone did, using an uncommonly-known name. Then uses the name everyone knows as a fun little reveal at the end of section. Why not totally off-topic... Well, he also seems to use it so that he can focus on the person's actions in the descriptive context of the person's time/inventions which he has been using up to that point. See, if he brought in the well-known name early, then he well effectively be changing the subject from what he was talking about to what people know about the famous person. And that harms his attempt to show a new angle on the well-known person. This is Somewhat similar to a pseudonym allowing an position/argument to float free from the particular individual stating it, and thus be judged on its own merits.
- forcefsck 15y agoAnonymity as "Anonymous Coward", someone on the internets with zero credibility said you were a bad student. Thanks to google super search powers, I know who you are, I'd certainly never hire you. Anonimity as "Certain Nickname on g+". Nobody knows his real name, but everybody knows his avatar and nickname and his real religious/political views. He has a certain credibility based on past facts. When I find hin irl, I'll kick his ass for insulting my believes. No anonimity, as we "know exactly who he is". He always posts about mainstream music and funny catz. He is a joy, always contributing positively in our community.
- DanBC 15y ago> Is it evil to put the interests of the entire network above the interests of a small minority? How many people have a $GIVEN_NAME $FAMILY_NAME (in that order, with a neat space)? How many people have a real name that doesn't fit those neat boxes? Your "small minority" is pretty insulting.