4 ms·
Democracy requires free speech. So, if you're against free speech, then you're also against Democracy. What form of government would you prefer? The biggest
by hedora 5y ago
Democracy requires free speech. So, if you're against free speech, then you're also against Democracy.
What form of government would you prefer? The biggest modern alternate examples are China (I'm guessing you disapprove of their zero covid policy, but your comment is ambiguous), and Russia (which also seems worse than the US according to the criteria I could tease out from your comment).
So, what concrete alternative do you propose?
- rxhernandez 5y ago> Democracy requires free speech. So, if you're against free speech, then you're also against Democracy. Why does democracy require free speech? Can I not vote for whoever I want even if I'm mute? > So, what concrete alternative do you propose? You get that there are many other countries in Western Europe that don't have as much free speech as the US right? You get that the lock down policies of many other Western countries seem Draconian relative to our policies right? You get that giving me some of the most extreme examples of alternatives makes it seem like you are arguing in bad faith right? Why do we need a brand new form of government? We didn't need a new form of government to ban saying "fire" in a theater.
- MisterMower 5y ago> Why does democracy require free speech? Can I not vote for whoever I want even if I'm mute? I think it would be extremely difficult for the electorate to make educated decisions about who to vote for if speech supporting a certain candidate is suppressed, for example. Free speech and the ability to vote are deeply intertwined. Without the ability to discuss candidates and issues openly, the electorate can’t make an informed, honest choice. If one candidate or side of the debate is suppressed or censored, that in and of itself affects the outcome of an election.
- Intermernet 5y agoIt seems extremely difficult for the electorate to make educated decisions about who to vote for due to the lack of consequences for completely misleading or false statements. Is a politician's lie protected by free speech?
- MisterMower 5y agoYes, as should be the speech of each person who points out the politician is lying. A prerequisite for a politician to experience consequences for lying is for people to be free to discuss the lie, persuade fellow voters that he is lying, and disseminate that fact freely. You’re not going to prevent politicians from lying by limiting speech. You’ll achieve quite the opposite effect, actually.
- Intermernet 5y agoFree speech doesn't mean consequence free speech. Someone aspiring to public office should be penalised for deliberately misleading voters. The imbalance of power and exposure means that the many people who correctly point out the lies and manipulation are unheard, while the perpetrator of the lies and manipulation can freely continue to lie and manipulate.
- MisterMower 5y agoThey will be penalized, by the voters, if people are allowed to discuss the politician’s actions and statements freely and make their own judgement about his fitness for office, and if they actually choose to do so. Ask yourself why those voices of truth go unheard. Or why the politician’s lies continue without consequence. Is it not because of a lack of robust speech around the politician’s behavior? Why doesn’t that robust speech occur? Sometimes it is suppressed. But more often, the root of the problem is that most people prefer to be lied to. Seeking and discovering the truth is hard work, and it is work that no person should outsource to a third party. Yet that is exactly what people do, when they rely on the press or media for the truth. Those organizations lie at least as frequently as the politician does.
- Karunamon 5y agoLiterally yes, because the next prompted question is 'who determines what political speech is true and therefore allowed?', which is a path fraught with dragons.
- 5y ago