3 ms·
Why “Staying Out of It” Backfires in Moral and Political Disagreements[pdf]
- jfengel 5y agoI said, in proper techie-libertarian fashion, that I didn't want to get involved in the politics of race. I said that to the black woman I was dating at the time. She pointed out to me that I was fortunate to be able to ignore such things. She couldn't, since she went out every morning being black. She was very kind when she said this. It wasn't an accusation, or as sarcastic as I've made it sound here. She was merely pointing out the obvious. It bothers me to this day that I didn't see it myself. That doesn't mean I have to throw myself at this problem. The world is full of problems, and I have to pick and choose which ones I'll spend my time on. There's a Jewish saying, "It is not your responsibility to finish the work of perfecting the world, but you are not free to desist from it either." That's something I believe in and want to live up to. In this case, it means making myself aware that "staying out of it" isn't something everybody can do. Being aware of it is the very least I can do, and saying "It's not my problem therefore it isn't a problem" is, in my view, morally wrong.
- jfoutz 5y agoThe only correct approach is [1] if by whiskey Not the logical fallacy, that would be a terrible thing that does nothing to support discourse, and actively makes it worse. but the rhetorical flourish, taking everything good and support it, while take everything bad, and reject it. That's a thing of beauty. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If-by-whiskey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If-by-whiskey
- spacemanmatt 5y agoHow is giving equal weight to both sides different than staying out of it?
- jfoutz 5y agoin highly charged political environments it's a status game. if you say nothing, you're implicitly on the wrong side for each listener (Backfires, like tfa discusses). If you hold up the virtues and tear down the corruption of each side, everybody only listens to the parts they want to hear. So you're on their side, or at least could be converted. Also, the comment was kind of a joke. The original speech in the wiki article is pretty darn funny.
- spacemanmatt 5y ago> So you're on their side, or at least could be converted I think the authors hold that the opposite is true because people see through such attempts to sit on the fence and judge that behavior more harshly than simply holding opposing views.
- XorNot 5y agoWhat does equal weight mean to you, when one side is calling for change, and the other wants no change? It's status quo conservatism: "I am content with how things are now".
- spacemanmatt 5y agoI don't know, it wasn't my example.
- spiderice 5y agoNot sure I agree with you take on if-by-whiskey. I read the excerpt from the speech in the link you posted. He isn’t “taking the good parts of whisky and rejecting the bad”. He simply stating what the good and bad are, without taking a side. Further, you can’t legalize the good effects of whisky while outlawing the bad. Whisky is either legal or illegal, and you accept or reject both the good and the bad. Essentially he’s pandering to his audience without making a stance on whether or not he supports legal whisky. How is that a “thing of beauty”? I think I kind of get what you’re saying. That we should have more nuance in our opinions. But I don’t think if-by-whisky supports that like you’re suggesting. Edit: I also realize I’m probably taking your comment to seriously. For which I apologize :)
- spacemanmatt 5y ago> Importantly, our account holds that people interpret attempts to stay out of it through the lens of social incentives, such that opting not to take sides should be judged more negatively to the extent that it seems strategically motivated. That hit all the way home for me.
- uejfiweun 5y ago> actors often try to “stay out of it” — communicating that they would rather not to take a side at all. Found the problem. Communicating that you don't want to take a side is tantamount to jumping into the debate. Completely idiotic. Staying out of it is a great strategy as long as you keep a low profile. If you're parading around saying "oh look at me, I don't like to take sides" then yeah, everyone's gonna think you're a massive prick. Just keep your mouth shut, keep a stone face, and try to be as positive as possible.