2 ms·
> It also seems clear to me that "well-regulated" is not there to be any part of the point of the Second Amendment. Well, it's critical to the point in that a
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> It also seems clear to me that "well-regulated" is not there to be any part of the point of the Second Amendment.
Well, it's critical to the point in that a working militia can serve a purpose, and a broken militia can't.
Contemporary documents make the point of the Second Amendment very explicit - its purpose is to prevent the United States from maintaining a standing army. But that's not what it does or what it claims to do; that's just the reason it exists.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Contemporary documents make the point of the Second Amendment very explicit - its purpose is to prevent the United States from maintaining a standing army. It's worth noting here that this is frequently cited and correct, but misses a critical point: this was before permanent paramilitary police forces, and one of the main reasons for fearing the establishment of a standing army is that this armed force with a distinct and insular culture from the citizenry would inevitably be used for internal security as well as against external enemies; the fear of standing armies is perhaps most accurately understood as a fear of permanent, insular domestic security services extending so far as to fearing permanent defense forces that could be turned to that purpose.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoI mean, you don't have to tell me. I'm on the record stating that the police are, by all definitions that do not refer to the actual word "police", a military body. Calling a soldier an "officer" doesn't mean he's not a soldier.