4 ms·
The political unrest is increasing, though. The risk of an election being rigged, overturned, or having the losing party refuse to acknowledge the result and ha
by pjc50 5y ago
The political unrest is increasing, though. The risk of an election being rigged, overturned, or having the losing party refuse to acknowledge the result and have parts of the state acceed to that is much higher than comfortable levels.
When you see a system that fails through four levels of safeties, and is stopped by a fifth, do you see that as "good the system is working" or "we need to re-examine the first set of safeties"?
- eschulz 5y agoYes it's unsettling that public figures in the current and previous administration have publicly expressed their belief that the 2016 and 2020 elections, respectively, were stolen. I wish that could be changed.
- turtledove 5y agoThat's a false equivalence, however. In 2016, stolen meant "gerrymandering, winning the popular vote but losing the electoral college, voter suppression" - real and measurable impacts to the outcome. In 2020, stolen meant conspiracy theories about people cheating at the polls with absolutely zero evidence that anything untoward had happened. In both cases, "stolen" is the wrong word, but to casually lump them together is also incorrect.
- skizm 5y agoThere absolutely was evidence for the 2020 election of Trump telling state officials to "find the votes" and giving them an exact number of votes he needs them to "find" for him to win.
- eschulz 5y agoI think many public figures, including Karine Jean-Pierre, pushed the narrative that Russia helped Trump cheat in 2020. But yes, the gerrymandering issue is also at play. Using the term "stolen" is very serious, and people in authority certainly must understand the power of their words.
- macilacilove 5y agoKeep in mind that from a European perspective the US has the _least secure_ elections among the countries that are considered democratic. Even some of the non-democratic countries have better elections.
- mywittyname 5y agoThis sounds like bullshit to me. US elections are regularly audited and recounts often produce the exact same result. The USA has low election participation, generally, inadequate polling locations in populous areas, the design of their senate is straight up stupid, and the electoral college should have been abolished a century ago. But the actual elections themselves are as secure as they can be.
- pjc50 5y agoThere's been significant worries over insecure or inadequate voting machine systems for years, all the way back to the "hanging chad" of 2000. However those have not been proven to affect any outcome yet.
- macilacilove 5y agoLack of photographic voter id in certain states, Mail in voting/drop off boxes, Transporting of Votes to counting locations, and other issues that raise security concerns. These are some of the bad practices that are generally rejected by countries that present themselves as democratic. Edit: also, how is it "their senate" this time, but "our democracy" in one of your previous comments? Have you lost your US citizenship in the last 2 hours?
- Ekaros 5y agoYeah, it's exactly kind of stuff that would be criticised in banana republics. And it is somehow okay in USA... Then again CIA did have huge hand in those republics, so it is reasonable to expect they might have used similar tactics at home... You never known, specially knowing how much the mainstream political machine hated the democracy.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoEquating the responses to the 2016 and 2020 elections is nonsense, most specifically because the loser in 2016 conceded. Yes, she may have blamed a host of other people besides herself, but she conceded, and the previous administration assisted with the peaceful transfer of power. Compare that with the 2020 election, where the loser is still going on national tours saying how the election was stolen and rigged after trying to get the result overturned, and many in his party believe him, and worse, many leaders in his party privately comment that this is all bullshit but publicly are silent or support his narrative.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoScarier is the fact that many states have indeed removed that "fifth level of safeties" by moving responsibility for declaring the outcome of elections from officials like the Secretary of State to the legislature.
- pjc50 5y agoOh, that's entirely intentional to allow the legislature to overturn elections they don't like.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoI'm highly skeptical we'll live in a country with free and fair elections for the rest of my life. It seems like a majority of people (or close) are vehemently opposed to free & fair elections - thinking the only votes that should count are they votes they agree with. And it seems like the VAST majority of people in this country would be willing to steal an election if it went in their favor. In this landscape - I'm not sure how it doesn't eventually happen. And once the genie is out of the bottle, I don't think it ever goes back in. When we live in a world where hardly anyone respects the opinions of others - it's hard to think a democracy is even what people want.
- ausbah 5y ago