3 ms·
> But, the collective labor pushback has stopped since the great offshoring took over in the last 30 years thanks to globalization, and various labor unions los
by mschuster91 5y ago
> But, the collective labor pushback has stopped since the great offshoring took over in the last 30 years thanks to globalization, and various labor unions lost their power
Not just that. A large portion of the loss of influence of unions was the riseup of the pacifist dogma. Just look how all the benefits were won: by (sometimes extremely) brutal violence, by the blood of the workers who died by the hands and guns of corporate goons [1].
A very good example is the social structure and workers rights of the two neighboring countries France and Germany. French workers are routinely willing and able to commit to violence both in the office (in the form of "bossnapping") and on the streets and the public supports that, and when German protests escalate into a couple of banks getting redecorated with paint, concerned citizens turn up to clean the fucking bank [2]!
As a result of that difference in attitude, German workers have it way worse than French workers - politicians in France know that the cost of going against the people is high. A society that doesn't fight for its rights eventually gets taken over by those that do. Democracy is not god-given, it is earned by blood and needs continuous maintenance, otherwise it erodes.
[1] https://www.investopedia.com/the-10-biggest-strikes-in-u-s-history-4773384 https://www.investopedia.com/the-10-biggest-strikes-in-u-s-h...
[2] https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/g20-in-hamburg-buerger-raeumen-schanzenviertel-nach-verwuestungen-auf-a-1156889.html https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/g20-in-hamburg-bu...
- blueflow 5y agoRe G20: The people making the mess were young activists, the article even mentions their group affiliation by name. They are not the working class, they are a nuisance to the working class. I'd be in favor of classifying them as terrorists.
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>I'd be in favor of classifying them as terrorists Same with Antifa. Some protestors are basically just mindless hooligans and their protests and property damage are harming the small business and working class people a lot more than the politicians and the ruling class. Like during the protests in France I kept seeing many mid-range Renault/Peugeot/Citroens on fire on the streets of Paris. Chances are those were most likely the cars working class people used to get to work the next day and not the cars of fat-cats. I agree with protesting violently against governments but what use is destroying working class property?
- pmoriarty 5y agoThe problem is that violence gets attention and sometimes conciliatory action like nothing else. Riots and terrorism generate world headlines, while peaceful picketing rarely gets anywhere near the attention (unless it's also met by violence, as the nonviolent demonstrations and sit-ins were during the Civil Rights struggles in the 60's). I am a pacifist myself, and am completely against violence, but I can see why some people who have less of a problem with it might find it strategically advantageous. The willingness to resort to violence is a great part of the reason that the world is as much a hellhole as it is now.
- mschuster91 5y ago> The problem is that violence gets attention and sometimes conciliatory action like nothing else. The thing is, the government itself is violent at its core: - cops beating up peaceful protesters or executing people on the streets - cops evicting people from their homes because they can't keep up with rent - cops arresting women because of miscarriages (over 1.200 in 15 years per [1]!) and soon because they dared to abort an unwanted pregnancy - social security systems, especially unemployment insurance, are purposefully laced with endless hoops to be jumped through, all in the name of denying as many people as possible access to these while still being able to claim that "we have a system for poor people" "Peaceful resistance" against this level of violence is a pipe dream. The insistence on "peaceful" resistance, the complete lack of material consequences for offenders acting as part of the government is the reason why civil rights are under attack by the government as harsh as they are at the moment. I'm not a friend of violence myself, but I absolutely refuse to look down on people for deciding to go the militant path in the face of the violence that governments are committing against the common citizen every day. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-59214544 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-59214544
- pmoriarty 5y agoSomething else to consider, for those that don't object to violence on moral or ethical grounds, is that violence is often counterproductive. If used against powerful governments it usually results in violent crackdowns which wind up killing off and/or imprisoning the leaders of the anti-government movements. When used against weak governments, the government may topple, but what arises in its place is often even worse than the toppled government, and that tends to be followed by much more bloodshed. If used against the populace it tends to cause both vigilante violent reaction and a resentment of the populace against one's cause. Violent action usually leads to violent reaction, and the moderates are killed off by those who are even less reluctant to use violence to achieve their aims. Countries thus afflicted not infrequently are plunged in to the horrors of civil war, which suits the extremists of every stripe, while ordinary people who just want to live their life are devastated.