4 ms·
Even high CO2 - which your brain does detect - won't be detected fast enough by your brain to do anything useful about changes that arise very suddenly, because
by tialaramex 5y ago
Even high CO2 - which your brain does detect - won't be detected fast enough by your brain to do anything useful about changes that arise very suddenly, because the sensor is measuring your blood, and high blood CO2 can mean you're seconds away from unconsciousness but with impaired cognition. You're screwed.
Humans will clamber down into a space that's been flooded with CO2 (to fight fires or by mistake), go, huh, that's not... er... bonk, and lose consciousness. Then others up top are likely to climb down to "save" the people who just fell over for no reason and suffer the same fate.
- NickNameNick 5y agoThis happened on a log carrying frieghter near here, a few years ago. The unprocessed logs in the holds are slowly rotting, so the air in the holds can be depleted of oxygen. A crewman went into the hold to check on something, and collapsed. Another crewman went in to rescue the first, also collapsed. I don't recall how many went in, but eventually someone grabbed an oxygen tank and managed to save the last one. The rest died.
- hnbad 5y agoI've watched a presentation on this problem that showed surveillance footage of this exact kind of situation happening and costing the lives of at least two people (I think the fourth one realized what was going on and got geared up before saving the last one to go in before him). You could watch them simply drop like flies, it was obvious they didn't realize what was happening to them before they fainted.
- _Algernon_ 5y agoAre you sure those cases are CO2 and not CO? Iirc CO is the truly fucked up one because it binds to hemoglobin much more readily than CO2 thus displacing both CO2 and O2 in the blood.
- agurk 5y agoWith CO the issue is that it binds to haemoglobin and stays bound to it permanently. Only a small proportion of CO2 in the blood is bound to haemoglobin (~10% [0]) so the real issue is that the O2 carrying capacity is reduced. As red blood cells are constantly being replaced limited exposure is not a long term issue, but this is a process that takes weeks. This means that someone with acute exposure cannot be helped with supplemental oxygen (or just being taken outside) unlike with CO2. CO2 in high concentrations causes issues through various mechanisms with a major one being that it impairs your ability to absorb O2 and other cellular disruption through increasing the pH of your blood [1]. This can cause unconsciousness in seconds at high concentrations and other potentially fatal impairments even at lower levels. So CO poisoning is worse as there's no (easy) therapy for it but it is still very possible to have fatal exposure to CO2 if you are not able to receive fresh air in a immediate time frame (minutes). There is also the general issue that confined spaces might be low on O2 as well, as described in this video on confined spaces in ships [2]. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK532988/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK532988/ [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5380556/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5380556/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNVj_JpZia8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNVj_JpZia8
- tialaramex 5y agoWith Carbon Monoxide there's a big risk of gradual poisoning. For example if you run a stove in a sealed compartment to keep warm, well, the Carbon Monoxide released can't escape and will gradually poison you over even several hours. If your body had a CO sensor, you'd realise there was a problem in plenty of time to flee, because it's so gradual, but it doesn't and so you might feel a little sleepy and that's it, you're probably never going to wake up. With Carbon Dioxide that gradual risk doesn't exist, you would realise there's a problem. You will probably even be woken if CO2 gradually rises, you'll become conscious, discover the air seems "stuffy" and go somewhere with fresh air. The problem in the drastic CO2 scenarios is it's too sudden. It's understandable (more so than with Carbon Monoxide) that we didn't evolve to cope with that. Prehistoric man did not use CO2 fire extinguishers.