4 ms·
Nooo! Public option is not a half measure, it's a ~zero measure. Single payer >>> public option. Public option is really easy to kill, just kneecap it any of a
by jjoonathan 4y ago
Nooo! Public option is not a half measure, it's a ~zero measure.
Single payer >>> public option. Public option is really easy to kill, just kneecap it any of a hundred ways, call it a failure, and then sell killing it as a tax break. It has the staying power of a cobweb on a car wheel. Failure is inevitable and it won't just be dead, it'll be held up for decades as proof that our government is uniquely incapable of doing insurance.
Contrast to single payer, which is hard to kill because people are yes paying a tax but also seeing a benefit and seeing a benefit that they didn't have before (healthcare doesn't go away if they lose employment). It doesn't suffer from adverse selection, it isn't an easy target for kneecapping, and it has a chance in hell of actually working.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoI would advocate for Medicare-for-all but that isn't going to happen in my lifetime. So if states want to try their own single-payer systems then go for it. But I'm still going to grumble if I see (yet another) big number taken out of my paychecks for it.
- tsol 4y agoHow/why is failure inevitable? >Contrast to single payer, which is hard to kill because people are yes paying a tax but also seeing a benefit and seeing a benefit that they didn't have before Isn't that true for a public option as well?
- upbeat_general 4y agoNo because it is a public option. Thus not everyone uses it.