5 ms·
I mean, is a video codec really just "math"? There's a binary payload description and algorithms involved for applying said math as well. I'm no expert in the
by cmrdporcupine 5y ago
I mean, is a video codec really just "math"? There's a binary payload description and algorithms involved for applying said math as well.
I'm no expert in the field, so I'm actually asking in good faith here...
- akersten 5y agoEverything you can instruct a computer to do is just math, yes. "Instructions on how to use the math" is, unsurprisingly, also more math. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lambda_calculus https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lambda_calculus
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI am well aware of the foundations of CS and the lambda calculus, but this is more than a bit reductionist, like saying "everything is made of subatomic particles." Patents on processes and methods are pretty common. Dismissing it as "they just patented some math" and then falling back to saying "oh, lambda calculus" -- I think you can do better :-) But, yes, I'm sure the patents suck.
- akersten 5y agoWhy should Free software advocates need to "do better" than to argue from literal first principles? Fourier could call his transform a "process" all he wants, but that does not make it patentable. So yes, "oh, math."
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoThese files have carefully constructed format though. To read and write the patented format goes beyond patenting math. I think cmrdporcupine was getting at something.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoYep, it's not like I think the patent is just. I think software patents are mostly junk. But saying "because it's math" is highly uninformative.
- alex_smart 5y agoFirst principles is fine, but where is the argument?
- Beltalowda 5y agoAlmost all inventions can be reduced to "just math", because after all, that's what we use to describe the physical world, and oh also computer software things. I'm not in favour of patents at all, but the entire "it's math" argument has always seemed exceedingly weak to me.
- drmpeg 5y agoB-frames (bi-directional predicted frames with a reference frame in both the past and the future) are patented. I'd say that's a process or method.
- djmips 5y agoI don't feel like you were asking on good faith after this response.
- alex_smart 5y agoI don't quite understand how you do not recognize that that is a strong argument against your position.
- FabHK 5y agoInsofar as GP seems to be against software patents in general, it is not an argument against his position, is it?
- alex_smart 5y agoIt definitely is. Church Turing thesis basically states that all systematic procedures can be encoded as math. So, software can be encoded as math yes, but also music can be encoded as math. Life can be encoded as math (which is what our DNA is). Rather than providing a basis of not allowing software to patented, I think it makes the statement "X can be encoded as math" trivially true - and therefore uninteresting. In so far as there is value in patents on any systematic procedure at all, the position that "software should not be patentable because it can be encoded as math" is completely untenable.
- t-3 5y agoThe difference is that music is not, in fact, math. The representation is abstract to the utility. With software, the math is the utility.
- jolux 5y agoWhat does “the representation is abstract to the utility” mean? I mean, music isn’t patentable, but it is thoroughly copyrighted.
- alex_smart 5y agoSoftware is also, in fact, not math. Nor is the math the utility of software. Software's utility (usually) is the business problems it solves. The processes are encoded as math, and a lot of writing software is about improving those processes, but that is not in fact the utility. Think of the guy who invented the equi-tempered scale. All throughout history you had to make instruments that are tuned to play in one scale. Now you can suddenly make instruments that can play all of them. Solves a real problem from music by making an improvement in the representation, so it can be viewed as all math. But is it really "just" math?
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoThe link you're looking for is curry howard correspondance
- em3rgent0rdr 5y agoEverything is math.
- gitgud 5y agohttps://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/purity.png https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/purity.png
- nceqs3 5y agoHere is a list of the essential patents from the main pool: https://www.mpegla.com/wp-content/uploads/hevc-att1.pdf https://www.mpegla.com/wp-content/uploads/hevc-att1.pdf Find a single US patent that "claims" maths as GP argued. It doesn't exist.
- monocasa 5y agoI picked first US patent listed (US 7,292,636), and it's first claim says > 1. For a bitstream comprising a first video picture, a second video picture, and a third video picture, a method of decoding comprising: computing a particular value that is based on (i) a first order difference value between an order value for the third video picture and an order value for the first video picture, and (ii) a second order difference value between an order value for the second video picture and the order value for the first video picture; computing a particular motion vector for the second video picture based on the particular value and a motion vector for the third video picture; and decoding at least one video picture by using the computed motion vector. That certainly sounds like math to me.
- Spooky23 5y agoIf you’re against patents, yes. If you’re gainfully employed doing math things that turn into codecs, no. Patents suck, but they also serve a purpose.
- dogma1138 5y agoI’m not sure why is this being downvoted… A patent for a drug is just chemistry, which is also just math with a specific ruleset… Patents are designed to protect work, especially work where most of the effort is in the research / discovery rather than the implementation. Implementing a video decoder is relatively easy coming up with the algorithms to encode/decode the video efficiently and effectively however is a lot of work.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe majority of the posters here are IT practitioners. Stupid patent rules get in the way, and there is a visceral reaction to them. It’s a tough, nuanced issue. I don’t think anyone is happy with the system, but many stakeholders have a vested interest.
- adrian_b 5y agoThere are essential differences between chemistry and mathematics. To discover anything in mathematics, including a new video compression algorithm, you do not need anything else, except a computer. In theory, not even the computer is needed, as you could do everything with pen and paper, but it might require years or centuries. Chemistry is an experimental science for now, until someone would find a method to solve the equations of quantum mechanics for non-trivial systems. A lot of mathematics is used in chemistry but at its base chemistry remains experimental, because all the mathematical models used in chemistry to predict some facts use a large number of model parameters that have been determined experimentally. There are no truly "ab initio" mathematical predictions in chemistry. Using mathematics in chemistry allows a significant reduction in the number of chemical experiments that must be done to discover anything new, but they cannot be eliminated yet. Any discovery in mathematics can be easily redone again, by someone else, completely independently, and this actually happens extremely frequently. There do not seem to exist many reasons that can justify why the later discoverers must be punished to pay money to others in order to use the mathematical relations that they have discovered themselves, even if by some chance someone else happened to discover the same relations earlier. For mathematical discoveries, there are little grounds to claim that the first discoverer should be able to recover any expenses, as most of the strictly necessary expenses are just in the salaries of people and it is very difficult to estimate what percentage of those expenses had actually contributed to the discovery. On the other hand, for inventions referring to chemical substances, or to mechanical, thermal or electrical devices and so on, a lot of experiments with physical devices must be made and the experimentation costs can indeed be very high, so it can be argued that it might be good for a society to encourage such experiments by promising a temporary monopoly for the exploitation of the results, as long as the duration of the monopoly is not excessive. For the kind of minor innovations that are the object of most recent patents, a reduced patent duration seems more appropriate, e.g. 10 years. A patent duration of 20 years or more seems acceptable only for a few patents for which the acceptance criteria should be much more strict than they have become recently, i.e. such patents should really be "non-obvious for those skilled in the field", and not just trivial combinations of formerly known devices or methods.
- MobiusHorizons 5y agoThe specification for the format (which is what is patented) describes the mathematical relationship between the binary payload and the uncompressed picture data. The actual implementation of the encoder / decoder is copyrighted and may also be patented, (which seems to be what you are alluding to), but with patent encumbered formats, the real issue is that the specification itself is patented. Practically this means that every encoder / decoder for patent encumbered formats has to have some form of licensing just to interact with the format even if they somehow reverse engineered the specification and built a cleanroom implementation (at least as far as I understand it, IANAL)