6 ms·
Abstract: "Americans’ hostility toward political opponents has intensified to a degree not fully explained by actual ideological polarization. We propose that p
by lapcat 5y ago
Abstract: "Americans’ hostility toward political opponents has intensified to a degree not fully explained by actual ideological polarization. We propose that political animosity may be based particularly on partisans’ overestimation of the prevalence of extreme, egregious views held by only a minority of opponents but imagined to be widespread."
You: "There's objective measurements that the democrats moved far left creating the polarization."
Hmm. Could it be that you're... overestimating?
- insickness 5y agoIn recent surveys, Democrats are found to be far more intolerant of Republicans than vice-versa. Young Dems more likely to despise the other party https://www.axios.com/2021/12/08/poll-political-polarization-students https://www.axios.com/2021/12/08/poll-political-polarization...
- breadbreadbread 5y agothats because Democrats are largely impotent whereas republicans have let fringe hateful ideas become their platform. If one person in the room smells like shit, can you blame other people for taking a step away?
- robonerd 5y ago> republicans have let fringe hateful ideas become their platform. In 2001, 23% of Republicans/Republican-leaning Americans supported same-sex marraige. By 2019, it was 44%. Among white evangelical protestants specifically, it was 13% and rose to 29%. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/fact-sheet/changing-attitudes-on-gay-marriage/ https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/fact-sheet/changing-att...
- breadbreadbread 5y agoaw thats cute. less than 50% of republicans think gay people can get married
- lapcat 5y agoIf I may inject a bit of dispassionate analysis here: I think there's a grain of truth to both sides. It's true that Republicans have moved more toward same-sex marriage. However, it also seems to be true that the legalization of same-sex marriage has politically activated many Republicans who are still opposed to same-sex marriage. When same-sex marriage was not legal, those opposed to it could remain fairly complacent. It was the status quo and wasn't an issue where they felt the need to engage in political activism. The most outspoken people were those in favor of same-sex marriage. But when same-sex marriage was legalized, there was an almost complete reversal, in terms of activism. So today it feels like Republicans are more opposed to same-sex marriage, even if the raw numbers say otherwise. But perhaps the raw poll numbers don't reflect the level of enthusiasm or activism regarding the issue. I think this is actually a general point: the level of political activism regarding any issue tends to be highest among those who feel threatened. So ironically, the level of activism opposed to same-sex marriage, for example, becomes higher as that view tends to wane in public popularity. A powerful overwhelming majority, on the other hand, doesn't need to make much effort to maintain its status.
- robonerd 5y agoCute? I am challenging your perception that Republicans let their "hateful fringe" take over. The data shows that Republicans have actually been getting more progressive. That this trend isn't fast enough to suit you is beyond the point, republicans trending in this direction at all (let alone doubling) contradicts your stated perception of the trend.
- breadbreadbread 5y agoYour statistic is based on the opinion of individual voters. My concern is with the forces in government that have made my friends in Florida fear that they cannot talk about their lives without being branded a pedophile. The sitting members of congress who think trans people are an abomination. The 20-something states that allow for conversion therapy for minors. But sure, I'm glad I can feel safe talking about marriage with 44% of rep. voters.
- filoeleven 5y ago
- watwut 5y agoActual laws actually enacted by conservatives are not middle of the road. Nor justices they pushed into supreme court. By that I mean that actual politic of both parties is different.
- bitwize 5y ago[flagged]
- anamax 5y agoI don't know how we're defining "an objective measure", but pushing CRT sure looks like "move left." So does "we're going to help your kid transition without telling you" and XYs in women's sports. Of course, one can argue that none of this is new, that what's new is pushback.
- dsr_ 5y agoPlease define what you mean by CRT so that we know what you are discussing. (I don't mean acronym expansion, I mean substance.)
- tastyfreeze 5y agoWhites are the oppressors and BIPOC are the oppressed. That anything and everything boils down to the color of your skin. That white Americans in particular are the sole perpetrators of historic slavery. That current white people should atone for the sins of past slave owners regardless of when their family came to the US.
- klyrs 5y agoWell, you're absolutely correct, inasmuch as that's a racist tire fire that shouldn't be in schools. But that's not "critical race theory," it's overwrought caricature that mainstream (and, in my bubble, even the quite radical) progressives would disagree with.
- tastyfreeze 5y agoCRT is a legal theory taught in colleges that is based on the ideas that are being taught in some elementary and secondary schools. No, CRT proper is not taught to children. Yes, the ideas that CRT is based on are being taught to some children. When the right says CRT is taught in schools this is what they are talking about. When the left and the media says that CRT isn't taught in schools they are talking about the CRT legal theory. https://areomagazine.com/2022/01/18/yes-children-are-being-taught-critical-race-theory-in-k-12-schools-in-the-us/ https://areomagazine.com/2022/01/18/yes-children-are-being-t...
- incomingpain 5y ago>Hmm. Could it be that you're... overestimating? As I said... wilfred social science... Here's a nice visual graph that I like: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/06/12/7-things-to-know-about-polarization-in-america/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/06/12/7-things-to... Go put your finger on the republican line and see where it moves. There has been analysis done by many groups which have confirmed where the political polarization derived heavily starting with gay rights. The republicans who had 'closeted' homosexuals moved left. Trump literally started a fight with russia and the middle east trying to benefit homosexuals. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/national-security/trump-administration-launches-global-effort-end-criminalization-homosexuality-n973081 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/national-security/trump-adm... The republicans clearly moved left and it was the right thing to do. Whereas Truman != Obama. It's rather easy to objectively see both parties have moved left. I feel like this is rather objective fact. The better discussion, why is this the case? Is it perhaps where the democrats have gone is the right place both parties eventually end up? Or are we about to watch 2nd civil war?
- mikkergp 5y agoI do think that people are so busy being mad about the "Democrats have moved too far left" meme that they haven't really thought about it. The problem being the definition of "too far left". But yeah, I think they've moved to the left because human rights are important. It would be interesting to go back to Women's suffrage because I'm sure people were having the same discussion. Liberals have moved left while Republicans have stayed where they are. But of course, moving to the left on equal rights for women is not liberals moving too far to the left. It's society course correcting. You don't get to say "Well liberals got women's rights so we get ____" But too many Republicans are saying the equivalent of that (hell some Republicans do https://www.news-leader.com/story/news/politics/2021/10/22/ann-coulter-says-women-shouldnt-have-right-vote-19th-amendment-missouri-state-university/8528256002/ https://www.news-leader.com/story/news/politics/2021/10/22/a... say exactly that.) Human rights can't be a partisan consideration. It can't be something we compromise over. We just have to evolve as a society, get over it and instead have substantive conversations about the policies that move the needle in people's lives.