3 ms·
Gifted Children, Youth Culture, and Individualism in 1970s and 1980s Britain
- gerdesj 5y ago
- ggm 5y agoInteresting study. I grew up in this period, in the UK in a street with three kids put in the Mensa box who basically I hated, because they were arrogant snobs. I tended to think this was because IQ and Mensa but I now realise, it was cultural mismatch from a jewish-austrian background, with a huge chip on their shoulder about their social exclusion. They were "different". They were bloody smart. Hothousing kinda worked. I also chose to walk off the IQ test game. I don't mean "my parents did this" I decided, off my own bat, to refuse to do them and asked my parents if they'd let me and they did. Age 10. As far as I'm concerned, for all but the margins this is junk science. I am by no means an autodidact, I had a normal traditional education to university level, and I continued for years to "know" I was the star in my own movie, a future nobel lauriate in a classic Walter Mitty dream, right up until i realised how average (and btw, happy) I was. I don't regret being average. I do regret not trying harder sometimes, and weed. So to the problem discussed here. Did the culture of the 60s 70s and 80s of intervention into what we now call "gifted and talented" help? I would argue despite the above, it probably did: an appreciation of the time, was the need to socially level up access to senior tertiary study and this window of time is when University was free, and entrance exams were non-exclusionary to working class kids. We have a massive cohort of people who graduated from uni, and the high end group-of-five big name universities because of this kind of programme. Imagine how hard it is to get outside the frame when your parents have no exposure to the richness of life, beyond the everyday. This kind of immersion for kids had a positive effect on some. If you want insights to the culture of the time, watch the "7 up" documentary series and reflect on the life outcomes for some of these kids.
- rhapsodic 5y ago
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoMight be anecdotal, but I have noticed in the recent years that there is a lot of push to set education levels as low as possible, to make most students pass their education, while failing the ones who are above average. "back in my days", we had some medium level of education, had additional classes (in some subjects) for the gifted ones (extra stuff) and for the almost-failing ones (repeating the stuff from normal classes), and it was still perfectly normal, that in a class of ~25, one or two students failed enough classes to repeat that year, especially in higher elementary-school years (elementary is ~7-15yo, so last 3 years of that) and in high school. Now it really seems that they went the "no student left behind" way. This might be different in countries and areas where you can just enroll your kid into a "better" school (as we can do with highschools here, but not elementary ones). I was one of the better students in my elementary school class, but when I went to a "better" highschool, the learning environment was A LOT better, mostly because the half-illiterate uninterested students (that somehow didn't fail enough times) didn't get enough points to get accepted to that school, and didn't cause problems those four years, even though grading on a curve meant a bit worse grades than before.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoEh, I think if the troublemakers are in the world, then you might as well have to learn about dealing with them as part of school too. This "the learning environment was better without the riffraff" just doesn't sit well with me. It's too easy of an excuse to justify segregation and classification, and self serving. I'm sure everyone there likes it and agrees with each other that it's reasonable, and I'm also sure that's not a good enough reason to do something. I overheard teachers making hay about my iq tests and was put into my school's g&t programs too, so, I don't say this from an opposite but equally self serving position. If we're so smart, then we should be able to figure out a good way to let the gifted grow without seperating and classifying everyone, and making some people too-aware how special they are over everyone else, and making other people who never did anything wrong, aware under no uncertain terms that they are limited and the cone of possibility for their life is already prescribed and small. If we're actually as smart as we tell ourselves, then why do we accept such a poor solution to that problem? The answer is smart people are not better people, but they will never tell themselves that, and they don't respect anyone else's opinion. The only counter to that is the exposure that comes from mixing.