4 ms·
Even the Amazon comments know that's a scam (well that and unavailable to actually purchase) and there is a reason the next disk in the list is 5x the price: >
by zamadatix 5y ago
Even the Amazon comments know that's a scam (well that and unavailable to actually purchase) and there is a reason the next disk in the list is 5x the price:
> A 2T SSD for $38 sound to good to be true and of course they are a scam, don't buy they don't work
But that's not even the biggest oversight here on storage, these drives also need to be attached to something which will need to be cooled, networked, and powered in a reliable enough way the service continues operating when you have 10s of thousands of these. You'll also need to store more than exactly the amount of data since you can't just lose videos any time there is a failure.
In all it's still going to be dwarfed by encoding and bandwidth costs but that doesn't mean 15k/PB is any less an order of magnitude or two off on storage costs.
- alex_young 5y agoI'm really sorry I posted a price I found on a simple Google search. Let's say you're right and SSDs are actually $150/TB. Now our 1 PB is still just $150k. Not even a fraction of revenue worth worrying about.
- zamadatix 5y agoIf the question was "how much would it cost to buy 1 PB worth of consumer grade SSDs" $150k sounds like a great answer. Going on the 1 PB/day Number that's ~$55M/year for some raw disk. Add another order of magnitude for needing more than just a raw disk to store 1 PB/day, as already explained, and that's ~500M/year on storage related costs. If you're hellbent on saying this half billion/year doesn't matter because the bandwidth cost (which is not paid per connection btw) would be much larger then sure but it's still unrelated to the cost of a standalone consumer SSD.
- alex_young 5y agoThat's not what I said. You've done this twice now, and I really wish you would respect the good faith principal others in this community value. I'll leave it at that.
- zamadatix 5y agoGood faith interpretation requires a stance to build off from but so far you've made direct statements about consumer SSD prices & bandwidth billing without a stance on how it supports your conclusion then been reactionary when it was explained these statements weren't accurate or directly representative of storage costs. Beyond having already added that bandwidth costs will still dwarf storage costs even when storage costs is a large number I'm not sure what other good faith interpretations could have been made. It's not like I only attacked the consumer SSD price in bad faith and left it at that, I followed up with why even a corrected consumer SSD price would not provide an accurate estimate which was ignored to focus only on the SSD price correction. If there is a further good faith interpretation of what you've said you'd like added to the conversation then please point it out here and lead by example. Only pointing out you think the other person should have better respected the good faith doesn't serve to help anybody understand better, in fact it goes against the principle itself. As it stands the most solid interpretation I can come up with is still that raw SSD pricing for a consumer, even though higher than listed, can come out low enough to be less than a percentage of revenue for YouTube but this still holds no indication about storage costs actually being that low but I'm always open to stronger interpretations!
- alex_young 5y agoHere are a few points you may wish to consider: - You claimed that the numbers I referenced were based on a clear scam. The resource is in fact the first resource you will find if you google "per tb storage cost". - You stated that I had made oversights about total cost, something I never referred to. - You claimed without any reference that the numbers I mentioned were off by multiple orders of magnitude. - You said I'm "hellbent on saying this half billion/year doesn't matter". I made no such statement and don't feel that way at all. - You said I was wrong about the way peering agreements are priced between ISPs and Google, but offered no other insight other than just saying I'm wrong. - You just called me reactionary. Again, I think it would be beneficial if you would respect the people you're interacting with enough to at least have a more constructive discussion.
- 5y ago