4 ms·
> anything that requires effort and "cultivation" to understand is not art. Tolstoy said that? Where? His work require a bit of effort and cultivation ... so d
by wolverine876 5y ago
> anything that requires effort and "cultivation" to understand is not art.
Tolstoy said that? Where? His work require a bit of effort and cultivation ... so does an incredible amount of art. Emotional communication does not at all exclude effort or cultivation; in fact, you can 'hear' a lot more if you sharpen your perception.
Cultivation seems hard to distinguish from any learning. Who is uncultivated, a four year old? Is art only what a four year old understands? That greatly limits what it can communicate to people who have become cultivated beyond that.
- brnaftr361 5y agoMy interpretation of what he intended more closely aligns with the word "pretentious". Artistic contributions that are veiled behind complexity and technique, or require explanation and close examination, and exposure. I can't speak to the native Russian texts, but the English translations of his work, I would surmise, could be understood by anyone. In the preface to the copy of What is Art? that I read, it was reported that Tolstoy struggled with the topic for some time, and that he struggled to adhere to the principals he laid that define art. But again, I'm butchering it, and suggest you read it for yourself. The peasant work song is art, Wagner's leitmotifs are pretentious.
- wolverine876 5y agoThanks for sharing that about Tolstoy. > The peasant work song is art, Wagner's leitmotifs are pretentious. So you have declared!