3 ms·
What are you asserting specifically? That there is no such thing as expertise?
by wolverine876 5y ago
What are you asserting specifically? That there is no such thing as expertise?
- knighthack 5y agoThere is such a thing as expertise. But in matters of taste, and specifically of wine-tasting, claims of 'expertise' have repeatedly been proven dubious. Run a search and you'll see why. There's a scam around that industry.
- wolverine876 5y ago> But in matters of taste, and specifically of wine-tasting, claims of 'expertise' have repeatedly been proven dubious. I don't know about wine tasting but I've seen many claims that, in fields where objective data is limited, there is no knowledge, no quality, etc.; that reality is some extreme of relativism where everything is arbitrary preference. (What a depresssing, flat nihilism that results in!) For example, it's often applied to the arts and to things challenging, 'highbrow' - things that tend to make people feel intimidated or inferior. The argument amounts to, 'if I can't measure it, it doesn't exist', and I think that is dubious. It's dubious not only on its face, but because most of what humans do requires subjective judgment; very little depends mostly on objective information. Finally, in fields where I've gained expertise (or more sophisticated perception), I've come to see that I had been missing out previously. I've seen those claims many times - and people often believe what is repeated, regardless of evidence - but not proven.
- alasdair_ 5y agoI am specifically claiming that I am not so sure an expert would be able to tell the difference in that experiment, given the video evidence that I’ve seen that shows that even the best in the world cannot always determine even basic aspects like the varietal in a blind tasting.
- wolverine876 5y ago> cannot always That's an impossible standard for anything (though perhaps you didn't mean it literally). It's not 100% success or nothing.