41 ms·
Florida Releases Reviews That Led to Rejection of Math Textbooks
- gigatexal 5y agoPolitics continuing to screw American kids from proper educations. The conservative right would kill itself to save an arm.
- rdtwo 5y agoAnd they left would do v the same to slip in a political woke message. I’m not sure why that’s needed in math class of all places
- gigatexal 5y agoSo you don’t want to support closing the wage gap? Interesting. Nothing I saw was particularly bent one way or the other. Just pointing out that inequalities exist in the context of a math book — you know word problems that are indicative of the real world.
- rdtwo 5y agoIf you are pointing it out in a context that it does not need to be pointed out you have a clear agenda. There are a lot of situations where you could construct a math problem that would be problematic. For example we could calculate costs of abortion or apperication of firearm costs. We could calculate the costs of killing Russian tanks all those would be highly political math problems.
- gigatexal 5y agoIt’s absolutely insane to me that we are having this conversation: politics is affecting math books ffs.
- rdtwo 5y agoYeah but I do have to admit that calculating combat costs and losses would make much more interesting and relevant math problems so I could see why you might be tempted to make a problem like that.
- gigatexal 5y agoLet’s look at this another way, a way that we might gain common ground on: by phrasing word problems like finding the average of something in the context of things that affect daily life like the salaries of women soccer players it might inspire a child or learner to want to learn more, research more, and by extension practice or learn more math. Making math interesting is one way to help kids better themselves in it. I think we can both get behind that. Now where we will differ is the text of these word problems but what if we had equal parts “woke”/non-“woke” text? Would that be a good enough compromise?
- phs318u 5y agoIf we ever get to a sci-fi future in which an all-knowing benevolent AI is governing wisely on behalf of the human race, it will surely have been trained on data points such as this. In the meantime, to me this is another crumb of data weighing on the side of American decline.
- orionblastar 5y agoPutting politics in math books is way offtopic.
- version_five 5y agoYeah I don't really understand the context in which it would be appropriate to have the math problems be left wing political parables. I assume if the vignette was about defending second amendment rights, or some calculation about number of abortions, it would be equally off-topic from the perspective of the state, but the left wing media would be jumping on how a publisher tried inserting right wing material into their textbook. Just because the NYT agrees with the politics, doesn't make the material ok for use in a math text. It's not about censoring it, it's about not sneaking any kind of politics into a math book.
- t-3 5y agoPolitics are everywere in life. I encountered tons of politics in grade school, from writing prompts to reading assignments, to history class, to the reading comprehension questions on the ACT. What is so special about math? Why are you more bothered about very tame politics than the obvious faults in the question?
- usrn 5y agoI don't remember seeing a single political problem in any of my math books (except maybe some extremely bland ones in statistics.) You can get by without them and they add nothing.
- t-3 5y agoThey do add something: interest and engagement. Relating mathematics to real-life problems helps learners to contextualize and think about math in ways that abstract equations do not.
- orionblastar 5y ago