8 ms·
Democratic communalism can sustain itself perfectly fine at the scale of a small village, or a neighborhood in a small town, or a single condo/HOA in a big city
by zozbot234 5y ago
Democratic communalism can sustain itself perfectly fine at the scale of a small village, or a neighborhood in a small town, or a single condo/HOA in a big city or suburban area. The whole question is what to do beyond that scale.
- kqr 5y agoWe have evidence that communalism (or at least something similar to it) has worked at large scales in the past. In fact, it ought to be one of the easiest things to get to work, because you don't have to coerce anyone of anything.
- lobocinza 5y agoLike if trust wasn't an issue.
- kqr 5y agoTrust is one of the most important issues! I trust my two-year old to carry his glass to the table because I've given him the opportunity to show me he can be trusted with that. I don't trust my two-year old to not fall down stairs because I've given him the opportunity to show me he can be trusted with that and he has failed to show it. That's how it works in an egalitarian society too. You give people a chance to show they can be trusted. If they fail to show that, you stop trusting them.
- lobocinza 5y agoBased on personal experience I don't see communal societies scaling. When you have a small homogeneous group of individuals trust isn't a issue because people are bound by blood, culture, ethnicity and everyone knows each other intimately but for larger groups instead of a big family you have multiple groups fighting for power and resources. So unless the society have mechanisms to deal with it it's fated to fail. Our present societies have many in place: private property, courts arbitration, elected representatives, etc.
- paisawalla 5y agoYour contributions to this thread have the tone of a wishful, rosey, cherry-picking trip through history motivated by the desire to arrive at a predestined conclusion: that we all should be living in a Communist utopia today, because it's logically the easiest and most available organizing system for humans. Therefore, we don't live in that world today only because intense energy and effort is directed into maintaining a non-optimal status quo. At least please provide some specific and tangible reasons why you believe this is so obviously true, instead of repeatedly alluding to these numerous, incontrovertible, imminently applicable examples. Your statements are, I imagine for most readers, directly opposed to what history has shown about human nature and the nature of power.
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago> that we all should be living in a Communist utopia today, because it's logically the easiest and most available organizing system for humans Socialism is what bootstrapped many ancient human communities, even if they didn't know the name It is known (and sustained by scholars) that many societies of the past were socalist in nature, hell, even Jesus teachings are considered socialist. It is by far more popular and spontaneous than feudalism, because it worked. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism#Early_socialism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism#Early_socialism
- lobocinza 5y agoSocialism as in euphemism for cultural authoritarianism?
- peoplefromibiza 5y agonote to self: don't ever talk about socialism in US centric forums. they won't understand.
- paisawalla 5y agoLet's assume that there's a consistent and coherent definition of socialism which could be applied to all of these civilizations, which there isn't. Rank these historical civilizations by technological progress, quality of life, territory held, and population. You won't find historical proto-socialism at the top end of that list. Why is that?