3 ms·
The more careful of (the critics), like Brenner, suggest that features of the current capitalist system—prolonged stagnation, politically driven upward redistri
by Animats 5y ago
The more careful of (the critics), like Brenner, suggest that features of the current capitalist system—prolonged stagnation, politically driven upward redistribution of wealth, ostentatious consumption by the elites combined with increasing immiseration of the masses—recall aspects of its feudal predecessor, even if capitalism still very much rules the day.
That's a property of feudalism, but societies with those properties are not necessarily feudal.
Feudalism is rule by local armed strongmen. The lower classes get protection from other strongmen in exchange for a cut of their resources. The strongmen can be warlords, drug cartels, military, or cops. Feudalism tends to result in clashes between local strongmen, and, often, consolidation when someone wins. That's how nations are usually created.
Economic oppression is common in feudal societies, but not limited to it. Capitalism offers more efficient ways to achieve economic oppression.
The paper goes off into classical Marxist analysis. The trouble with Marx as a guide is that he wrote in an era of direct labor. Output was a result of the routine efforts of the proletariat. Wealth was the result of taking a cut of those efforts. The inputs from labor exceeded those of capital.
Today, you look at a balance sheet, and "cost of goods sold", which includes direct labor, is often a minor item. Marketing and G&A often exceed cost of goods sold. This turns the assumptions of Marxism upside down. In many industries, a majority of corporate expenditure is devoted to battling competition and changing things, rather than just making the product. This breaks not just Marxism but much of classical economics.
It's what drives industries towards monopoly today. It's not about having the biggest, most productive steel mill. It's about establishing market dominance so you don't have to compete on price. Or on wages.
Peter Thiel's "Zero to One" notes "Avoid competition as much as possible." That's the key idea here.
This is not feudalism. It's oligopoly. In some ways it's worse. In a feudal culture, the strongmen have some obligation to provide protection for their peasants. Oligopolists have no such obligation.
- eli_gottlieb 5y ago>It's what drives industries towards monopoly today. It's not about having the biggest, most productive steel mill. It's about establishing market dominance so you don't have to compete on price. Or on wages. Might one call it, perhaps, "the highest stage of capitalism" ;-)? Beyond the joke, I do often find myself thinking that the oligopoly and rentier tendencies described by terms like "neo-feudalism" are pretty much just the things designated by the old Marxist usage of "imperialism". But then the problem is that "imperialism" has been watered down into "everything your local sectarian Marxist group doesn't like."
- drewcoo 5y ago> But then the problem is that "imperialism" has been watered down into "everything your local sectarian Marxist group doesn't like." That's a very Leninist view of Marxism. [1] If you're hearing that, it's likely from tankies. [2] [1] https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1916/imp-hsc/ https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1916/imp-hsc/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tankie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tankie