6 ms·
> Several were veterans of the company, with more than six years of experience I think it's sad that we have an industry, where someone with six years' experie
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
> Several were veterans of the company, with more than six years of experience
I think it's sad that we have an industry, where someone with six years' experience, is considered a "veteran."
But it sounds like Amazon is sending a message to managers of other warehouses, to go as low as possible, to fight unionization.
Expect things to get ugly.
- whycombagator 5y agoWell the line you quoted says company not industry. Ecommerce is a relatively young industry anyway. And Amazon has been around since what, 94? So 6 years is over 20% of the time Amazon has existed.
- k__ 5y agoSo, if a company exist 1 year and someone worked there for 6 months, they're a veteran?
- zoover2020 5y agoRelative to the company, yes
- MobiusHorizons 5y agoIt’s not a technical term, so it’s always going to be somewhat of a matter of opinion. If I had to guess, you could only really be described as a veteran at some company if you had been there longer than most other employees. It seems like at least 60 or 70% of the employees should be newer.
- baitedandrated 5y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoFair point. I just found it to be an interesting choice of words. Whenever they use the same term, in other industries, they are talking about double-digit tenures. The main point is that this is a fairly unambiguous message to other managers, that allowing unionization to happen under their watch would be a careericidal offense. That means that they can expect the warehouse managers to get pretty desperate, and probably break all kinds of laws and whatnot. It's just that the message is being sent in a way that allows the company to keep their hands clean, from the almost certain results. The managers will certainly get fired, if unionization happens, and might get fired, if they get caught, spiking the trees. Guess which path the managers are likely to take?
- ethbr0 5y agoAmazon's done this with most of their functions. Push expectations: claim no responsibility for outcome. Walmart laid out the playbook that profits in a thin margin market require you being an asshole to your counterparties, but blackmailing them into still working with you via scale.
- jachee 5y ago> That means that they can expect the warehouse managers to get pretty desperate… It would seem to make sense for all the warehouse managers themselves to form their own union.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thinkling 5y agoAmazon's workforce has probably doubled twice in the last 6 years? So even without taking attrition into account (which is substantial in the warehouses), after 6 years you're in the 25% longest-tenured warehouse employees. With attrition I'd guess you're in the "top" 10%?
- glenngillen 5y agoIt was doubling somewhere between every 12-18mo while I was there (circa 2017). The growth was nuts.
- coredog64 5y agoThere’s an “old fart” tool that shows you how many people were hired before/after you.
- donthellbanme 5y agoYou know those help wanted commercials Amazon floods media with, "We pay $15 to start, blah, blah. Start a new career." I just assumed they were always hiring because of consistent growth. According to the guy (forget his name. Wears a gold chain.) representing the union; Amazon fires a lot of employees. Many for no reason. (I once read a restaurant success book. Everything he recommended made sence, except one, and it does make sence, but it's weaselly. His recommendation to restaurants was to fire all employees every six months. Turn over the semi-skilled completely. His reasoning was a new employee didn't complain, didn't steal (this was before companies had cams everywhere, gps tracking, and wrist movment counters), and worked harder.) I believe this is Amazon strategy. It's usually a bit harder to fire union workers for no reason. Fire them before they can see the inequities in the company.
- coliveira 5y agoYou're completely right. Amazon strategy is to maintain constant turnover, so that employees never feel they have stability and can't complain of anything.
- wardedVibe 5y agoAnother benefit of firing workers early is it increases churn, which makes forming unions in the first place difficult, since it relies on trust between workers.
- oicU00 5y agoSame idea seems work in public favor when firing politicians frequently: https://www.nber.org/papers/w29766 https://www.nber.org/papers/w29766
- infiniteL0Op 5y ago
- Ekaros 5y agoHaving watched the HVAC videos about restaurants and walking freezers with doors left open by new employees causing problems for hardware and their operation in general. Maybe that isn't best solution. Then again maybe returns on other side cover any such issues... Which I rather doubt that you can train them in all things in that timeframe...
- avgcorrection 5y agoI think the sad part is getting fired over union association.
- hungryforcodes 5y agoBoth!
- Taniwha 5y agoThese managers are getting fired because they had been put in charge of stopping the union forming - this is a threat to the managers at other Amazon locations to be more evil - "pour encourager les autres"
- mynameisash 5y agoWhen I left Amazon (as an SWE), with about 11mo of tenure, I was apparently at about median longevity. Yes, some of it is their growth, but a significant reason is also that they churn through people unnecessary. It's ridiculous to me that a big tech company treats people so terribly and continues to get away with it.
- tpmx 5y agoCurious: Where do you feel the SWE people they churn through generally end up? I'm a bit concerned about this one guy on one of my previous teams who moved from Europe to US to work on AWS. I don't think he was aware of the company culture.
- vmception 5y agothey end up at other companies of similar size, its part of the circuit, colloquially called FAANGs.
- lamontcg 5y agoa lot of them head to startups or smaller companies.
- oneepic 5y agoIf one starts in Seattle, I'd expect them to end up at Microsoft, Expedia, other FANGs maybe, among other co's. Assuming they're not burned out.
- tekknik 5y agoBurned out at amazon is on point elsewhere.
- aynsof 5y agoThe CEO of Cloudflare has said that he enjoys taking burned out SDEs from Amazon and giving them a happy life at his company. It's how, in his words, Cloudflare can compete at an engineering level with AWS.
- psychlops 5y agoBy industry consideration, you mean the new york times? Seems they just reviewed a few linkedin profiles and chose that word.
- WalterBright 5y ago> to go as low as possible On the other hand, it could be to not give the workers a reason to unionize.
- SrslyJosh 5y agoLOL, LMAO
- WalterBright 5y agoI see you think this is a win-lose system. Free markets, however, are a win-win system. Both parties must win for the transaction to happen. The employer-employee relationship is just another transaction, and should be win-win. If a manager sees it as win-lose, he should be fired. The same goes for an employee. I've been an employer and an employee, and always recognized that it should be a win-win relationship and approached it from that angle.
- oblio 5y agoThis is a very naive approach. Some market corrections happen very late (decades later) and some never happen.
- AndyKelley 5y agoI moved to Seattle from my hometown of Phoenix out of college for my "dream job" at Amazon. I started interviewing for other employment after just three months. I ended up quitting after eight months. Amazon is a horrible place to work. Six years is a lifetime there.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway12948 5y agoI have seen this sort of sentiment many times, and the narrative here aligns with the main thread. I also know a few in my circle who I respect and think very highly of, but only worked at Amazon for ~1 year, and all of these people have been very quiet about their experience at Amazon. Also, I understand that the leadership principles are taken very seriously. My question: How are the leadership principles used in a way that leads to such a bad experience?
- KerrAvon 5y agoThe problem at Amazon as I understand it is extremely darwinian stack-ranking. The leadership principles don’t address this. Even if you have a team of 10 senior high achievers by every metric, some percentage of them have to be managed out every N months. It’s absolutely insane. If Apple did this, they’d never ship hardware or software updates.
- zdragnar 5y agoA small part of the problem that's I observed during my interview there is the person who interviewed me mentioned that the teams largely operate independently, and sometimes have competing ideas. First across the finish line wins. Ultimately, this, I think, sets up a lot of perverse incentives. Engineers are encouraged to burn themselves out to beat their coworkers, and there's less value in maintaining a good product. Anyone who remembers the very early days of their cloud offerings could pretty easily see the results.
- michael1999 5y ago
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> I think it's sad that we have an industry, where someone with six years' experience, is considered a "veteran." What does it take to be considered a "veteran" in the military? > The term "veteran" means a person who served in the active military, naval, or air service, and who was discharged or released therefrom under conditions other than dishonorable. ( https://www.va.gov/OSDBU/docs/Determining-Veteran-Status.pdf https://www.va.gov/OSDBU/docs/Determining-Veteran-Status.pdf ) > Most first-term enlistments require a commitment to four years of active duty and two years of inactive ( https://www.military.com/join-armed-forces/making-commitment.html https://www.military.com/join-armed-forces/making-commitment... ) A veteran is someone with experience. Why wouldn't six years of experience make you a "veteran"?
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoAround these parts, "veteran" is usually used to designate military servicepeople that served during times of active conflict, yet it seems pretty much any soldier that was honorably (or, at least, not dishonorably) discharged, is able to access the VA health system (we have a VA hospital in my town, and I know quite a few veterans). I'm not so sure about other benefits, like schooling, loans, and insurance. My father[0] was a veteran. He's buried in Arlington. Got a silver star, a bronze star, and a purple heart. His GI Bill benefits got him a Harvard LLB. I am not even close to a military veteran. I did work for a company for almost 27 years though. In this community, that elicits a lot more scorn, than it does respect. [0] http://cmarshall.com/miscellaneous/MikeMarshall.htm http://cmarshall.com/miscellaneous/MikeMarshall.htm
- navbaker 5y agoA military veteran is pretty much anyone who served, doesn’t need to be in times of active conflict. Source: https://www.va.gov/OSDBU/docs/Determining-Veteran-Status.pdf https://www.va.gov/OSDBU/docs/Determining-Veteran-Status.pdf
- galfarragem 5y agoIn my mind - and in most, I believe - a military veteran means a war veteran.
- nimbius 5y agoI disagree Its a common stall tactic for large businesses to fire leadership after a Union is formed. It means you cannot facilitate a good faith negotiation and places the union in a perpetual limbo that can last years.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoGood point. I was unaware of this tactic, but it makes sense. Thanks!
- nimbius 5y agoIf you're wondering what the play from unions is after this, its "unexpected" equipment breakdowns and coordinated slowdowns because you now generally lack the leadership necessary to fire people or lead failure/productivity investigations
- CountSessine 5y agoThe funny thing is though that for warehouse employees at Amazon, their job is so simple and all of their work is wrapped up and recorded for KPIs that if they slow down or become unproductive, they could be fired electronically without even assuming that the slowdown was intentional. They’re hamsters on a wheel and the wheel isn’t going to slow down just because they’re upset about their situation.