5 ms·
Citizens reject proposed South Africa law linking biometrics to SIM cards
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Proven 5y ago
- Synaesthesia 5y agoWe already have RICA which means you need to provide identification and proof of address when buying a SIM card, at least in theory. This is really unnecessary and a violation of basic privacy.
- jonathanlydall 5y agoTheir stated rationale for doing this is to reduce the incidents of SIM/number hijacking. Speaking as a South African who in 2019 ported my number to a different service provider, this was the SMS (verbatim) I received when I ported my number: > MTN has received a request to port your number. If this is incorrect, please reply 1 to this SMS within 45 minutes. Which I (and I expect most people reading this) consider a terrifyingly bad process. What if for some reason I didn't see my messages for an hour, or was on a flight or something? Assuming the process hasn't changed, then there are much less drastic options they can look into first.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoAlso: "1"?? At least make it a different code every time. Before looking at biometrics they should first fix the regular processes..
- weird-eye-issue 5y ago> At least make it a different code every time. Why?
- homero 5y agoIf somehow you can send a spoofed reply to that number you'd have to guess the code
- jodrellblank 5y agoWhy would someone want to spoof a “do not port the number” message? It’s 1 to cancel not 1 to approve.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoOh good point, I didn't notice that. But that makes it even worse. It should require a confirmation, not offer a cancellation. I was confused because that's how it works here.
- dbetteridge 5y agoEven better. OPT IN not OPT OUT Ask the person to confirm they wish to proceed and get them to send a pre-arranged code that was given when requesting the port.
- nonrandomstring 5y ago> Governments across the globe that introduced biometrics in SIM cards > as part of the on-boarding process, to clamp down on fraud, include > China, Afghanistan, Mexico, Pakistan, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, Jordan > and Venezuela. This list of countries should tell you everything you need to know about the spread of techno-authoritarianism. I've spoken to Nigerians who say they've had enough and want out due to overbearing and corrupt government there. They tell me that corruption is both perpetrated by the government and then used as an excuse to clamp down on personal liberties and freedom of business that ultimately benefits corrupt government officers. It's a vicious downward spiral fuelled by digital technology. We need much more stuff like Declaration for the Future of the Internet [1]. Though I don't see how that can directly help people in these kind of regimes when we allow our own companies like Bluecoat [2] to export oppressive technologies. [1] https://www.internetgovernance.org/2022/04/29/the-declaration-for-the-future-of-the-internet/ https://www.internetgovernance.org/2022/04/29/the-declaratio... [2] https://slate.com/technology/2013/01/blue-coat-citizen-lab-report-says-the-silicon-valley-firm-sold-internet-surveillance-equipment-to-authoritarian-regimes.html https://slate.com/technology/2013/01/blue-coat-citizen-lab-r...
- sofixa 5y ago> It's a vicious downward spiral fuelled by digital technology. Aided more than fuelled ( fuel implies that if it's cut the fire will stop). The history of corruption and opression show no technology is required for that, but it certainly helps.
- natly 5y agoHard to look forward to a VR/metaverse future with these trends continuing.
- klipt 5y agoWhy, wouldn't you want to spend your entire life in a virtual world completely controlled by a single mega corporation? /s
- mistrial9 5y agocould we re-phrase this with some stark language? of course "metaverse" participation can be cut at any time from behind closed doors, and of course individual finances are linked to these virtual worlds.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoindia has had that for quite a few years now without any "uproar" because it is seen as "quick and easy" as compared to filing out paperwork and spending time getting photocopies of documents and having them authenticated and what not
- nine_zeros 5y agoThat's only because the government hasn't yet figured out how these tools can really be used to suppress opposition.
- LightG 5y agoWow ... that's really sad to hear.
- headsoup 5y agoLack of uproar does not mean lack of problem.
- selimthegrim 5y agoAt least patwaris are mad?
- briandear 5y agoWhy the need for documents and having them authenticated in the first place? Why does the government have a compelling need to track everyone?
- Hnrobert42 5y agoIt’s interesting that the comment cited links this proposal with communism, UBI, and a global government. I wonder if that comment is representative of most of the objections.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoYeah it was a bit crazy. A lot of people seem to think that South Africa is a "communist" government, which it really isn't. Some of his other comments were also outlandish.
- orasiscore 5y agoSame in Ghana
- nicolas_t 5y agoIn HK, I recently received a message from my prepaid sim provider telling me that I need to link my passport number to my sim card within a year or my phone number with be suspended.
- em-bee 5y agoin singapore you can't buy a sim card without an ID for at least a decade, in germany since 2017, and most other EU countries now require an ID too. https://netzpolitik.org/2017/interaktive-karte-registrierungspflicht-fuer-prepaid-sim-karten-in-europa-weit-verbreitet https://netzpolitik.org/2017/interaktive-karte-registrierung... http://umap.openstreetmap.fr/en/map/prepaid-sim-card-registration_155856#5/47.025/15.996 http://umap.openstreetmap.fr/en/map/prepaid-sim-card-registr...
- selimthegrim 5y agoDo these go for the eSIMs you can buy online too?
- ThePowerOfFuet 5y agoNope.
- churchill 5y agoNigerian here. The initiative to link SIMs with biometrics kicked off after that highly-publicized series of ENDSARS protests protesting corruption, police brutality. The protests were eye-opening for the government (that popular resistance could be organised without people ever meeting in person) so they want better tools to link you finances, etc. to your communications. Roughly three weeks ago, telcos started disconnecting numbers that haven't been linked with biometrics & I've been barred from making calls since then.
- freebuju 5y agoAm curious. How do you make calls now? Did you resort to using Whatsapp for calling your contacts? How do you call your grandma back in the village?
- churchill 5y agoI can spend weeks without calling anyone but I'm currently using a SIM registered by a sibling for those few times when I really need to. Can I walk over to the NIMC (Identity Management commission) office to get one? Yes. Will I? We'll see about that. Oh, and I forgot to mention that the process of getting the national identity number is fraught with corruption and you might typically need to pay under the table to fast track it. Just another Saturday in the "Giant of Africa."
- exolymph 5y agoThis comment was inexplicably dead so I vouched it.
- zo1 5y agoPretty much useless uproar because biometrics are already stored in the national ID card. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_African_identity_card https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_African_identity_card
- smokey_circles 5y agoI hadn't heard of this. Doesn't matter. RICA requires you to give a current and valid proof of address and government issued ID when buying a sim card. Biometrics is unnecessary. Also probably useless, given how often those systems are broken
- ryzvonusef 5y agoIn Pakistan, we have to provide our National ID card number and a Biometric thumb print to get a SIM, (or do anything basically) not that it helps, because apparently they caught a gang using silicon thumbs to get sims https://customstoday.media/fia-arrests-gang-using-fake-silicone-thumbs-for-cybercrimes/ https://customstoday.media/fia-arrests-gang-using-fake-silic...
- abdullahkhalids 5y agoWell, it is kind of stupid that they don't immediately check the thumb print for the SIM card with the print associated with the National ID card. I don't see a security risk with the Telco sending NIC-number+thumbprint combo and receiving a Yes/No if they match or not.
- throwaway8486 5y agoHow to deal with this in case if this happens in any country? All i can think is to use voip over tor? Any other thoughts?