> So if it’s going to make that much money per year and that’s “independent of supply and demand” then why should the U.S tax payer help fund the project? Beca

> So if it’s going to make that much money per year and that’s “independent of supply and demand” then why should the U.S tax payer help fund the project? Because growing the economy by $461 million a year grows the economy and hence tax receipts, which then can be spent on good things or on reducing taxes. Note that that’s $461 million for one industry. Reducing shipping costs has benefits that accrue to everyone who uses goods that are shipped on internal waterways or sells them, i.e. everybody. Doing things that benefit everyone is very much in the bailiwick of the government.