4 ms·
"When PayPal mysteriously and arbitrarily decided to freeze everyone’s donations..." "...We had raised $45,000 in just a few days, and then PayPal froze our ac
by dangrossman 15y ago
"When PayPal mysteriously and arbitrarily decided to freeze everyone’s donations..."
"...We had raised $45,000 in just a few days, and then PayPal froze our account."
Not so mysterious. Believe it or not, no payment service is going to allow you to collect tens of thousands of dollars in a few days with just a name and an e-mail to identify you. The criminal abuse would be rampant. If that doesn't raise the red flags at the risk department of any processor they'd be out of business in no time.
Just another rehash of the same story we've seen on HN a dozen times this year, as recently as ~2 weeks ago with the game developer taking preorders for an undeveloped game -- who eventually satisfied PayPal and later wrote a post about how Google Checkout was worse and PayPal was not so unreasonable after all.
"Yes, you heard that right. PayPal gets to earn interest on all of our donations for 6 months"
If PayPal's agreements with its underwriting banks are anything like the rest of the merchant processing world, then reserve accounts are always non-interest-bearing to prevent any incentive to create them without proper justification.
- pc 15y ago"Believe it or not, no payment service is going to allow you to collect tens of thousands of dollars in a few days with just a name and an e-mail to identify you." Using the email address and name is hardly the best way to evaluate the trustworthiness of Diaspora. There are lots of reasonable questions about how to scale underwriting systems, and how this might work generally, but we shouldn't neglect the fact that in this particular situation 1) Diaspora not being able to receive donations is a bad outcome, and 2) there isn't exactly a paucity of public information about them.
- dangrossman 15y agoFor all PayPal knows at the point they freeze the account, it's some teen in Romania that has no connection to the project and is using its name to collect donations for personal use. First they have to stop the potential fraud from growing even more damaging to them by freezing the account, then they need to figure out who they're really working with, then they need to evaluate the risk of accepting those payments.
- pc 15y agoFrom the post: "Even though we’ve complied with every PayPal request, including providing them with our certificate of incorporation, they still won’t give us an explanation for any of their moves." It seems that Diaspora weren't unwilling to verify their identity.
- dangrossman 15y agoYes, although the blog post that their account was frozen is dated yesterday, so who knows if anyone at PayPal has even had a chance to review it yet. That indie developer (I forget their name to look it up again) had also posted on their blog that their account was closed, then a few days later PayPal reversed itself and reopened it -- that may still happen here. I hope it does, as on its face Diaspora doesn't seem like an organization that would attract too much risk.
- fungi 15y ago> with just a name and an e-mail to identify you. try harder. from TFA: Even though we’ve complied with every PayPal request, including providing them with our certificate of incorporation, they still won’t give us an explanation for any of their moves.
- dangrossman 15y agoThat's a bit of a rude way to start a response. First, PayPal had zero verified information about the identity of the account holder at the point the account got frozen. The information Diaspora sent happened after PayPal requested it when their huge increase in incoming funds triggered the account review. That was posted just yesterday, PayPal probably hasn't even had a chance to look at whatever they sent yet. Second, this same comment was already made and responded to an hour ago.
- fungi 15y ago> That's a bit of a rude way to start a response. your right, sorry.