4 ms·
Oh man, I didn't expect to read a comment saying "it's OK if 100 times more cars have accidents as long as a company isn't liable".
by stavros 5y ago
Oh man, I didn't expect to read a comment saying "it's OK if 100 times more cars have accidents as long as a company isn't liable".
- tra3 5y agoThat's not really what the OP is saying though, is it?
- stavros 5y agoTrue, it was more "the company would rather have 100k accidents it's not liable for rather than 1k accidents it is". Doesn't make it much better for me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- doctor_eval 5y agoI read the parent as meaning to say that because Mercedes will be liable, even 1,000 accidents will be a real problem for them. This is a good thing because it shows that Mercedes expects a very low number of accidents while the system is enabled. Mercedes accepting the risk like this is a massive step forward for these reasons. It sets a precedent that hopefully others will follow. They wouldn't transfer the risk if they didn't think it would profit them.
- stavros 5y agoI guess, maybe I misunderstood. I was just surprised to read "it's better to have a ton of deaths, rather than a few deaths we're on the hook for".
- crooked-v 5y agoOn the other hand, if incautiously switching from the former to the latter drives your company bankrupt, the end result doesn't benefit anyone.
- ghostpepper 5y agoFrom the company's point of view this is correct reasoning. The sooner people realize companies do not have any responsibility to be moral the better
- jfoster 5y agoIt's actually a human thing. When bad things happen, we strongly prefer that they don't happen as a result of something that we did.
- maxerickson 5y agoThey absolutely do have responsibility. There's no reason we should allow investors limited liability if they are going to be assholes about it. Corporations should only exist because they are net beneficial to the public! I do agree that enough companies are unethical that it is reasonable to expect it.
- kortilla 5y agoThis is just naive. Every company that makes any kind of product has made some kind of trade like this. Costco sells you knives cheaply because they will not be liable if you murder people with them. If the Costco investors were liable for murder every time one of their knives was used to kill someone, you can bet they would just not sell them entirely. Just because a company thinks about liability doesn’t mean it’s immoral. Individuals avoid liability as much as possible too (see insurance). The world is dangerous and “fault” is everywhere.
- maxerickson 5y agoI'm not sure what your point is. My comment is a statement that corporations do have a responsibility to act in the interests of society, not an analysis of the particular ethics of selling knives or avoiding liability.
- kortilla 5y agoSo do people, which are the ones that run companies. What’s your point?
- deaddodo 5y agoFrom a corporate perspective, of course it is. It's the Ford Pinto study all over again. This is why corporate influence on legislation is bad, as their "best interests" often come at odds with morality-based ones.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hedora 5y agoFight Club summarized the Pinto thing nicely: https://www.quotes.net/mquote/31826 https://www.quotes.net/mquote/31826 without providing the illusion that such cost benefit analyses are a thing of the past. (Pintos had a problem with the gas tank, not the differential, but it's pretty clear what they were referring to.)
- oconnor663 5y agoI feel like almost any summary of the form "so you're saying it's ok that..." is almost without exception not something the other person would agree with.
- MereInterest 5y agoThat's kind of the whole point. If a decision or policy has predictable consequences that aren't being addressed, either the decision-maker is unaware of those consequences or is accepting of those consequences. Asking the question removes ignorance as a possibility, and lets the conversation continue. Sometimes the answer is "No, I was unaware, and I will adjust my decision." Sometimes the answer is "Yes, here are the consequences of the alternatives, and here's why I believe this set of consequences to be best." Sometimes the answer is "Yes, I don't care about those people." By asking the question, these three types of answers respectively give the other person an opportunity to improve themselves, give you an opportunity to learn from the other person, or give the audience an opportunity to learn not to trust the other person.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago> Sometimes the answer is "Yes, I don't care about those people." Frequently true but rarely admitted
- endominus 5y agoYou missed one option; "You're falling prey to the is-ought fallacy." That is, saying that something is true is not the same as saying that something should be true. The original claim was that from the perspective of management at a company, 1,000 accidents the company is legally liable for is worse than 100,000 it isn't. Which is true! From that limited perspective! The reply "so you're saying it's ok that..." implies that the comment agreed with that perspective, which isn't necessarily the case. It could simply be pointing out a failure state of current management practices and corporate law. But further than that, that phrase is usually a particularly uncharitable one, and I find this usage of it to be more common than any other. I think "implying the speaker believes that the unfortunate condition they pointed out is right and just" is the normal use case for that phrase, rather than trying to bring attention to the consequences of a policy.
- Aperocky 5y agoMost car accidents are 100% operator error, it'd be really far fetched to try to blame those on the manufacturer. Autopilot not so much, the point stands.
- dghughes 5y agoLaunch control option added by car manufacturers I'd say is 100% the car manufacturer's fault they thought of it, installed it, promoted it, but it's pointless and dangerous.
- zaroth 5y agoIt clearly has a point, because they successfully market and sell the feature. And everything is dangerous to some degree. Clearly it is not 100% their fault because the feature can certainly be used responsibly. Is there a more nuanced and substantive form of your argument against developing and selling a launch control feature?
- Anonymous4272 5y ago>launch control How many accidents happen from a standstill? Id love to see some stats, but i highly doubt it would be a high number