5 ms·
That threshold is generally considered to be 20mph. Below that speed pedestrian injuries are unlikely to be fatal. It's what urban speed limits are in Sweden,
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
That threshold is generally considered to be 20mph. Below that speed pedestrian injuries are unlikely to be fatal.
It's what urban speed limits are in Sweden, and they average about one pedestrian death a year in the entire country.
- Closi 5y ago20mph is considered to be good for survivability, but is not really good from a speed/travel perspective. I believe OP meant maybe 40mph is a good balance between the two factors of speed (higher is better) and survivability (higher is better) from a corporate risk / insurance perspective. Raising one of these lowers the other - so the actual threshold depends on how you value speed / convenience vs accident survivability / risk, and what you want to market your car as able to do (few consumers will see a 20mph self-drive speed limit as a viable self driving system).
- zip1234 5y ago20mph is within populated areas and not on a main road. In the US, the norm is 25mph, which isn't that far off.
- hgomersall 5y ago25mph is >150% of the energy at 20mph. It's a big increase.
- FabHK 5y agoAnd not only that. In a situation where, with 20 mph, you can just come to a complete stop before the child, with 25 mph initially you'd hit it with 15 mph. vr = (c^2 - 1)^0.5 v1 where v1 is the original slow speed with which you'd come to a standstill just before the obstacle, and v2 = c*v1 is the faster speed, and vr the speed with which you hit the obstacle coming in with the faster speed (assuming you hit the brakes at the same spot, and constant deceleration).
- hgomersall 5y agoIndeed, as an interesting aside it's a 3-4-5 triangle. 25^2 - 20^2 = 15^2
- Closi 5y agoThat comes with it’s own challenges - ie limiting speed to 20mph in the UK would realistically mean it can only be used in areas where there are schools and lots of pedestrians - ie less chance of an incident being fatal but possibly more chance of an incident.
- judge2020 5y agoIt's limited to highways as well (hence the geofence), so they probably don't expect VRU incidents to happen much, if at all.
- easytiger 5y agoThe reduction from 30mph to 20mph in London is political CV padding and has had no real effect on outcomes. All based on Chinese whispers. Wouldn't be surprised if your comment ended up as an original source in Islington's justification for some thing or other. It's that flimsy
- stefan_ 5y agoAverage speeds in London are below 20mph. Accelerating absurdly overweight, overpowered cars to anything over 20mph in between stops at lights is just a moral hazard.
- easytiger 5y ago> Accelerating absurdly overweight, overpowered cars to anything over 20mph in between stops at lights is just a moral hazard. The level of absurdity in suggesting a moral element to driving a car at below 30mph just shows how fundamentally biased people have become about a normal part of everyday life. For whatever reason
- hgomersall 5y agoIf it doesn't it's because it's not enforced. It's irrefutable that vehicles moving at 20mph are less dangerous than vehicles moving at 30mph.
- easytiger 5y ago> If it doesn't it's because it's not enforced. It's irrefutable that vehicles moving at 20mph are less dangerous than vehicles moving at 30mph. Then make them drive at 1mph
- dwighttk 5y agonot gonna be a lot of pedestrians on the highway, are there?
- zaroth 5y agoThis is only on highways. Survivability is concerned only with passengers not pedestrians.