3 ms·
To me "truly new," as you keep using it, does imply something from nothing - some aspect of innovation or creative spark that doesn't simply involve the transfo
by krapp 5y ago
To me "truly new," as you keep using it, does imply something from nothing - some aspect of innovation or creative spark that doesn't simply involve the transformation of existing data or basis in existing knowledge. Otherwise, what is the difference between "truly new" and simply "new?"
>The idea that electrical transmission over wire is just a better smoke signal seems to deny the most basic differences between the two, or that there was any ingenuity or human contribution in the path from one to another.
No, I think we simply disagree on the nature of ingenuity. I argue that there is no aspect of human ingenuity or creativity that cannot be simulated by a machine of sufficient complexity because the human brain itself is simply a complex machine. It's just data processing - we do it every night when we dream. There's nothing ineffable separating the two that makes it possible for a human to innovate but impossible - even in theory - for a computer.