This would be a welcome discussion on Effective Altruism forums :) I really think there's little credible attack on Effective Altruism -- it's like trying to a

This would be a welcome discussion on Effective Altruism forums :) I really think there's little credible attack on Effective Altruism -- it's like trying to attack science as a whole. Of course you should be altruistic (in a general sense, particulars can vary), and of course you should be effective in your altruism. The details of what it means to be effective and what are the ethical goals that define altruism are part of the process -- and input is not only welcome but essential in refining it.