3 ms·
The value I gave hugely understates oil's useful energy. Even so, the energy equivalents shown are huge. But if you want greater accuracy: A human being cons
by dredmorbius 5y ago
The value I gave hugely understates oil's useful energy. Even so, the energy equivalents shown are huge.
But if you want greater accuracy:
A human being consumes ~2000 -- 3000 kilocalories per day.
A human produces only a fraction of that in useful work output:
- Total metabolism is only so efficient, I believe on the order of 25%.
- That 2000 -- 3000 kilocalries/day gives you 96--145 watts constant output. That's where the "a person produces 100 watts of (thermal) energy at rest comes from. About 1/4 of that, 25 watts, is required simply for your brain.
- People can work only so many hours per day, and at relatively low constant output.
The net available work is probably closer to 1/10 to 1/4 the net output. So a litre of oil -> 30 days of actual delivered effort by a human.
Of course, burning oil for mechanical energy results in about 70% losses through Carnot efficiency, so we can divide by 3 and get about 10 days of useful mechanical energy, roughly 3x greater than the raw dietary comparison I'd made above.
On the true cost of oil, I'd make another argument which is that if we consider costs to represent the true costs of production, then the fact that oil is created through an immensely inefficient conversion of ancient sunlight to biomass to kerogenic materials over hundreds of millions of years, and we're extracting it at roughly 5 million times its rate of formation, the production cost value should be about 5 million times that of present biomass.
The PeakOil discussion is looking at the net value basis. That also increases the price, but "only" by a factor of thousands, not millions.
If you look at the delivered GDP per barrel of oil (dividing national GDP by oil consumption), what you find for most countries is a value somewhere between $400 and $3,000/bbl. The lower values are for India and China. The US tends to see about $1,000 GDP/bbl, most of Europe $2,000/bbl, and Switzerland about $3,000/bbl. Some poor, low-oil-consumption nations do better (Mali did when I last looked into this), but that's more a testament to how little oil they consume rather than how efficiently they process energy in bulk.
Given valuation of $0.5 -- $5 million based on actual work / true cost of formation, use of oil as presently practiced is absolutely noneconomic. It makes about as much sense as burning $100 bills for heat. (I'm presuming non-inflated currency.)
- zasdffaa 5y agoVery solid answer, thanks, and also to @wcoenen