4 ms·
So how many do you need? I'm disappointed that the question wasn't answered.
by charcircuit 5y ago
So how many do you need? I'm disappointed that the question wasn't answered.
- CGamesPlay 5y agoThe pile of bananas larger than Manhattan is how many you need to power a single house.
- geoffpado 5y ago“Even if you captured that decay energy with perfect efficiency, powering a house would require about 300 quadrillion bananas, which would form a heap large enough to bury most of the skyscrapers in the NYC metro area” 300 quadrillion
- josephcsible 5y agoIt was answered. You need 300 quadrillion bananas if you only use the energy emitted from the radioactive decay, or 10 bunches per day if you're willing to just burn them and basically ignore their radioactivity.
- charcircuit 5y agoI expected the article to actually calculate it and not just give the answer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mkl 5y agoI thought this was a pointless quibble, but then I tried doing the calculation myself (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31284436 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31284436), and I think Randall got the number wrong.
- iclelland 5y ago> > I'm disappointed that the question wasn't answered. > It was answered. And now disappointed that the article only answered the question? :D
- charcircuit 5y agoI couldn't initially find the answer because I was looking for a calculation to find the answer instead of just a sentence out of the blue with the answer
- dredmorbius 5y agoCody's Lab has shown how to extract potassium from bananas. Spoiler: most of the potassium is in the peels. https://yewtu.be/watch?v=fmaZdEq-Xzs https://yewtu.be/watch?v=fmaZdEq-Xzs 10 kg of bananas. 6.56g flesh, 3.44 kg peel. 6.56 kg banana flesh -> 1.5 kg dried bananas (plus about 100 g corn starch, used to prevent sticking) Flesh pyrolised in a charcoal kiln to 0.5 kg banana charcoal. Peels -> 0.12 kg. Charcoal burned down to 67g (flesh) and 51g (peels). Potassium precipitated out as potassium chlorate. 33g flesh, 41g peels. Decomposing out oxygen -> 36g potassium chloride (potash) (combined, flesh + peels). Radiation was measured at this point with a Geiger counter, at about double the background rate. Metalic potassium produced through an alkalai converter, though only at about 50% yield: 9g produced rather than the 18g expected. The initial potassium chlorate yield was also below that suggested by FDA nutrient standards. Cody discusses this in the video. Slow-mo exploding potassium banana sequence at end.
- t_mann 5y ago300 quadrillion, it's right in the text. Next to the visuals showing how large that pile would be.