3 ms·
Didn't the LHC confirm the existence of the Higgs boson? That sounds pretty valuable to me. What lies are you talking about? Coca-Cola makes US$37 billion a
by kragen 5y ago
Didn't the LHC confirm the existence of the Higgs boson? That sounds pretty valuable to me. What lies are you talking about?
Coca-Cola makes US$37 billion a year (almost five LHCs, thus 50 times the average annual budget during the LHC's construction) by making people obese with flavored sugar water. Some of this involves lying, but much of it is just emotional manipulation; vanishingly few of its customers receive anything of value. So far none of its executives have been imprisoned as a result.
(Petronas Towers wasn't funded by voluntary contributions, either. Petronas has a state monopoly on oil and gas extraction.)
I agree that it would be better to fund basic research like the LHC from voluntary contributions. (I think dominant assurance contracts are a promising attack on that problem, but I don't know if they will succeed.) But if you take traditional academia and taxation as a package deal, I think most people would prefer to live in a world with the 15 recent enormous contributions to society by traditional academia I listed in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31275875 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31275875, including modern agriculture, solar energy, and Linux, than in a society without them and without taxation.
These are public goods, and it's a well-known result in economics that markets underprovide public goods; the equilibrium result is that they almost don't provide them at all.
Even within the realm of taxation, academic research is hardly the hot spot. Most countries spend almost no tax money on academia. Even in the US, whose federal budget is US$6600B, NIH gets US$42B (0.7%), Pell grants get US$35B (0.5%), NASA gets US$23B (0.5%), NSF gets US$8.3 billion (0.1%, which includes basically the entire particle physics budget), and DARPA gets US$3.4B (0.05%). If you wanted to reduce the US tax burden, most taxpayers wouldn't even notice if you reduced the federal budget by this 1.9%. The rest of the federal budget is literally fifty times as big.
- lisper 5y ago> What lies are you talking about? The claims about confirming or ruling out supersymmetry.
- kragen 5y agoWell, so far all the results are consistent with supersymmetry, so in that sense it's provided confirmatory evidence. Are you saying that someone promised much stronger confirmatory or falsificatory evidence?
- lisper 5y agoAny results are consistent with supersymmetry because supersymmetry is not a theory, it is a family of theories, entirely analogous to Ptolemaic epicycles. For any set of data you can contrive a supersymmetric theory that fits that data. But the claim that was made for the LHC was that it would either produce evidence in favor of a particular set of supersymmetric theories, or that supersymmetry would be considered falsified. Neither of those things has happened. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=96VECuUXbEs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=96VECuUXbEs particularly starting at the 6:20 mark (but the whole thing is well worth watching).