4 ms·

Show HN: Interactive Circle of Fifths

45 points by CosmosSeb 4y ago

jweissman 4y ago
absolutely love this project!! will definitely use this as compositional aid... a few thoughts: - it would be nice to go "the other direction" here too -- from a set of chords, tell me the possible ambient key environments - the only thing ux wise i can pick at is the squiggly underline - support for modulation would be amazing (a basic query there might be just "find any/all common chords between two selected key environments")
tejohnso 4y ago
Pretty good as a visual and auditory reference. But it could use a bit more detail on the why / how. For example, it shows "C major scale" with notes CDEFGAB. But then when you click the Cmaj button it only plays CGE. Why only three notes? A chord can have more than three. Why those specific ones? Why is it that notes CDEFGAB make up the C major scale? I guess it gets complicated, and that's why there are so many links to external sites for more information.
- andybak 4y ago
  I'm not sure it's meant to teach music theory. As you observe, that would get complicated. > But then when you click the Cmaj button it only plays CGE. Because those are the notes in Cmaj > Why only three notes? A chord can have more than three. Yes but not Cmaj. I don't know if you're asking these questions yourself or putting yourself in the place of someone who is learning theory - but it seems a strange criticism of a single page interactive website that it fails to explain the vast amount of arbitrary information embedded in western standard practice.
allears 4y ago
Whenever I click on a tonic key, the inner wheel flies off the screen and disappears. I can only get it back by closing the page and re-opening.
unfolding 4y ago
I am always happy to see so much music theory content here. I have a bachelor of music for my undergrad, and working on my mscs at the moment. There must be a lot of people like me who discovered their love / interest in computation through music theory.
JimmyRuska 4y ago
Very Good !
joshxyz 4y ago
Damn I thought it's Interactive Circle of Filths.
- ChrisRR 4y ago
  It sounds horrible, but it's actually quite beatiful

45 points by CosmosSeb 4y ago

absolutely love this project!! will definitely use this as compositional aid... a few thoughts: - it would be nice to go "the other direction" here too -- from a set of chords, tell me the possible ambient key environments - the only thing ux wise i can pick at is the squiggly underline - support for modulation would be amazing (a basic query there might be just "find any/all common chords between two selected key environments")

tejohnso 4y ago

Pretty good as a visual and auditory reference. But it could use a bit more detail on the why / how. For example, it shows "C major scale" with notes CDEFGAB. But then when you click the Cmaj button it only plays CGE. Why only three notes? A chord can have more than three. Why those specific ones? Why is it that notes CDEFGAB make up the C major scale? I guess it gets complicated, and that's why there are so many links to external sites for more information.

andybak 4y ago
I'm not sure it's meant to teach music theory. As you observe, that would get complicated. > But then when you click the Cmaj button it only plays CGE. Because those are the notes in Cmaj > Why only three notes? A chord can have more than three. Yes but not Cmaj. I don't know if you're asking these questions yourself or putting yourself in the place of someone who is learning theory - but it seems a strange criticism of a single page interactive website that it fails to explain the vast amount of arbitrary information embedded in western standard practice.

allears 4y ago

Whenever I click on a tonic key, the inner wheel flies off the screen and disappears. I can only get it back by closing the page and re-opening.

unfolding 4y ago

I am always happy to see so much music theory content here. I have a bachelor of music for my undergrad, and working on my mscs at the moment. There must be a lot of people like me who discovered their love / interest in computation through music theory.

JimmyRuska 4y ago

Very Good !

joshxyz 4y ago

Damn I thought it's Interactive Circle of Filths.

ChrisRR 4y ago
It sounds horrible, but it's actually quite beatiful