5 ms·
This chart [1] was making the rounds a while back. Whether you totally agree with its methodology or not, it certainly suggests that many people consider a huge
by ghaff 5y ago
This chart [1] was making the rounds a while back. Whether you totally agree with its methodology or not, it certainly suggests that many people consider a huge swath of Netflix' content average at best.
And for someone like me who doesn't watch a huge amount of video, that's not a great look. Tastes differ of course but my tastes aren't that out of the mainstream. And I'd rather a streaming service had a modest number of high quality shows than a whole lot of meh.
[1] https://twitter.com/loudmouthjulia/status/1516794978105794560/photo/1 https://twitter.com/loudmouthjulia/status/151679497810579456...
- whoisjuan 5y agoThat graph isn’t showing that. Sure, Netflix produces way more content than competitors but they also have more shows in the far right (outstanding and exceptional) than their competitors.
- dfxm12 5y agoRight. I don't care about the shows/movies I don't want to watch on a streaming service. I only care if there are enough shows/movies on there I do want to see.
- bawolff 5y agoI also don't want to spend large amounts of time researching what i want to watch. If there is one good show with poor discoverability burried under a mountain of crap, that is still a product failure.
- brimble 5y agoThe ratio of OK-or-worse to good-or-exceptional sure appears to be a less favorable for Netflix than the others. Though people's rankings seem crazy to me. Apparently just producing a Star Wars thing and not totally shitting the bed in the process counts as "exceptional". Then again... yeah, that's kinda true, I guess. From a certain point of view. Still, better than nearly all shows on all those services? Yikes. I dunno about that.
- ghaff 5y agoHence my comment about the methodology. And HBO Max doesn't have anything that's exceptional? For that reason, it doesn't really make sense to focus on the specifics of a handful of outliers as unreliably ranked by RT (I think). The real message is that large as Netflix' catalog is, it doesn't necessarily have a lot more highly ranked content than other sites have. (Which roughly squares with my anecdotal impressions.)
- mikkergp 5y agoBut doesn't this? Medthodology aside, taking the data as is, Netflix has like 30 programs outstanding or better. The next best is like 10. Weird about HBO Max though. Maybe because they don't consider HBO shows as 'streaming'. At least Succession should be in exceptional. If not a lot more, if you include the older work.
- Auracle 5y agoThe fact that Titans is slightly higher ranked than Peacemaker on HBO is insane. The data would be more interesting if it could be broken up by demographics. My wife (along with a lot of women) likes reality tv, and Netflix has a fair amount of that. I personally can’t stand it.
- mikkergp 5y agoWhile Ratio is usually the right way to evaluate things. Is that applicable in this case? Doesn't what matters is the number of good shows not the percentage? If I watch Netflix I can find three Exceptional shows and a bunch of Outstanding shows, including three at the high end of outstanding. If I watch Apple TV + There are no exceptional shows and only one at the high end of outstanding, but the ratio seems better. I guess it would depend on discoverability.
- brimble 5y agoIt matters if they're not spending less for each show, on average, than other services. If you're dropping $20m a season, on average, and so are your competitors, but more of yours are duds, that's bad. If you're dropping $5m to your competitors' $20m, maybe it's not a problem if, say, twice as many of your seasons are bad. But, part of the trouble with this analysis, as far as sussing out the above issue, is season-count. How many Netflix originals are as long as, say, The Sopranos? Or The Wire? How many are only one season, or maybe two? It's possible (possible! I do not know) the hours-of-original-content difference between Netflix and the other services isn't as large as this suggests. Or that it's even larger. Hard to tell. I'd say that this chart points toward bad things for Netflix, but without some other pieces of data it's hard to tell what it's actually saying.
- ghaff 5y agoThey don't really have that many more shows well out to the right; it's mostly a draw. (And at that point you're talking pretty small numbers.) But it's pretty clear from the graph that, as a percentage of their total shows, more Netflix shows are just OK than the other services. (Now if the bulk of that is very cheap drek to boost the size of the catalog, that's OK I guess. But I doubt that it is.)
- ChrisLomont 5y ago>They don't really have that many more shows well out to the right; it's mostly a draw. Netflix has significantly more in the outstanding category: for example, I count around 8 for Disney, 11 for Apple, 10 for HBO Max, 8 for Hulu, and at least 39 for Netflix. I don't know how you call that a draw. And I don't really care about the average show, since I (and I suspect most others) are not uniformly randomly sampling movies to watch with zero input from others. I (and I suspect others) watch those that are rated as good movies, and in that case, Netflix is crushing the competition by the numbers in that chart. Netflix, by that chart, provides a lot more shows rated good, outstanding, and exceptional.
- ghaff 5y agoAlthough most of those Netflix shows are on the far left of that category. There are a lot of ways you can interpret the info and a lot of good questions that it doesn't really answer. But it is interesting that Netflix clearly looks different from others.
- cgriswald 5y agoThere is a disconnect between what I want and what providers are trying to offer me. I want quality content with powerful search. Providers seem to think I want a huge unsearchable library from which they will make recommendations. Netflix has lots and lots of great original content, but given a random show, it's far more likely to be average or less (versus, say, HBOmax).
- ghaff 5y agoOn the other hand, a lot of people are fine with putting unremarkable content on as largely background noise. That's what a lot of broadcast TV was. So there's probably at least some market for a large catalog of OK stuff rather than more of a focus on prestige TV.
- mikkergp 5y agoThere was a while where they were talking about providers making a lot of Niche Content. I wonder if they need to do a better job of adapting to personas. I love the Victorian/Edwardian Farm series that are on Prime, and I think of shows in a niche as sort of "beyond rating". i.e. They are never going to get the money to be considered "exceptional", but will be draw just as strongly for people who appreciate that niche. (Deep not broad). So can Netflix create a curated and simpler interface that optimizes for Outstanding/Exceptional or period pieces or whatever instead of just a long list that's hard to grok.
- autoexec 5y ago> Providers seem to think I want a huge unsearchable library from which they will make recommendations. Providers want to act as gatekeepers who have the power to make something popular by limiting your options to alternatives. Sometimes they also want to be able to accept money for heavily promoting specific things over others. It's not about delivering a quality product to you at all, it's about what gives them money/power at your expense.
- ipaddr 5y agoI had HBO and tried to watch every show. There are plenty of ho-hum shows. An HBO show has a theme and style their own which makes getting into a show a lengthy affair only to realize it's not what you really want. Netflix sums up the show in a preview making it easier.
- Spooky23 5y agoHow would you know? Between deliberately bad search and a bias towards pushing you to waste time rather than entertain, they bury their own content and deliver swill. Netflix got away with it because they were the only game in town. Disney really broke the seal and delivered a good platform. Apple is delivering strong content that compensates for the horrific application.
- quickthrowman 5y agoThe chart doesn’t include HBO originals. I’ve never seen a Netflix show that is on par with the best HBO content.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI would put Narcos up there.
- colinmhayes 5y agoI would not. It's not even close either.
- selimthegrim 5y agoAs long as you’re not comparing it to El Patrón del Mal, Narcos: Mexico wasn’t half bad.
- whimsicalism 5y agoTo The Wire? No way
- omegalulw 5y agoI don't know about other people, but finding something to watch on Netflix is frustrating, there's so much poor quality shows. The recommendations are not good (tbf that's most streaming services) and there's no option for granular filtering. For example, I hate dubs, I would like to pick shows where the original audio is some particular language, I don't get why that isn't there? In contrast, on HBO Max / Disney+, usually there's far less content but since the quality is better you can easily pick something to watch.
- autoexec 5y agoI agree, netflix might be too embarrassed by their catalogue to show people a simple A-Z listing of everything they have, but I'd absolutely watch netflix more often if they did. Scrolling through the same shows I'm not interested in over and over across their multiple random/useless categories takes up way too much time. Every so often I'll go to search and enter random 2-3 letter combinations because I usually find a bunch of stuff I'd like to see but Netflix has been hiding from me.
- slowmovintarget 5y agoI have to wonder how much of this is to favor cache hits for streams over picking the bytes up out of storage. That is, if a bunch of people are streaming a show, it's easier to add a few more and reuse the edge cache. Most viewers won't go beyond the recommendations, so the back-catalog pulls are less frequent, and less pressure on the infrastructure. Total speculation, though.
- vitus 5y ago> how much of this is to favor cache hits for streams over picking the bytes up out of storage. Netflix's catalog historically has been small enough that it can fit within a single rack. With 8Mbps [0] bitrates for 4k (okay, add 50% for transcoding to lower resolutions, so let's call it 12Mbps), we get about 5.4GB per hour of video. At 360TB for a single 2U Open Connect storage device [1], that translates to 67k hours of 4k video. This article from 2020 [2] indicated that US Netflix's catalog was about 36k hours. Even at 50% growth since then it would still comfortably fit on a single machine. [0] "The highest 4K bitrate on average is 8 Mbps which is also a 50% reduction compared to 16 Mbps of the fixed-bitrate ladder." https://netflixtechblog.com/optimized-shot-based-encodes-for-4k-now-streaming-47b516b10bbb https://netflixtechblog.com/optimized-shot-based-encodes-for... [1] https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/appliances/#the-hardware https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/appliances/#the-hardware [2] https://www.whats-on-netflix.com/news/how-long-would-it-take-to-watch-all-of-netflix/ https://www.whats-on-netflix.com/news/how-long-would-it-take...
- jandrese 5y agoEyeballing the chart it looks like the percentages for each section are roughly the same for each service, Netflix just has a lot more shows so they fill in the "just average" box more than the other services.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThe HBO section only includes the "max" shows. All their best shows are "hbo originals" so they're actually doing much better than it looks.
- saghm 5y agoYeah, I was confused by GP's phrasing as well. Maybe I'm taking the word "average" too literally and this is just one of those "5 stars good, 4 stars okay, 3 or fewer stars is garbage" things, but wouldn't the expectation be that the average show is...average? Unless you think that Netflix is has some reason to be more likely to make good shows than anyone else, it seems like their shows should be on average, average.
- rmatt2000 5y agoIs anyone else's OCD triggered by the x-axis on that chart?
- Thorrez 5y agoWow yeah, that's bad. It took me a while to realize what's wrong with it. It seems logarithmic, but actually just between the boxes is logarithmic; inside each box is linear. That's why the points have such a strange distribution, clustering toward the left of each box. The clustering is a visualization of Benford's law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benford%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benford%27s_law
- Thorrez 5y agoFunny that Netflix's top "original" (in fact, the top show in the entire graph), Cobra Kai, was actually a YouTube Original for the first 2 seasons. Disclosure: I work at Google, but no on anything related to this.
- cheriot 5y agoWhere are these ratings from? If Cobra Kai and The Witcher are exceptional I'm done with TV entirely. Netflix is slowly reinventing cable. Reality shows, cooking shows... all of these cheap production things has an audience. Who am I to judge?
- ghostly_s 5y agoThe only meaningful thing this chart is telling me is that Netflix produces an absurd volume of content.
- riffraff 5y agoI enjoyed Cobra Kai and The Witcher but "exceptional"? Who the hell votes this stuff?
- troelsSteegin 5y agoFrom the chart, Netflix has a lot of titles, relative to the other channels. I would think they could lean hard on recommending titles to niche audiences - getting viewer returns from titles in the long tail of popularity. But, my experience as a viewer is frustrating - all I see are the Netflix recommendations for me - browsing, exploring and discovering are tedious. I see less than 5% of their catalog through their UI. I would like an "experience" over the Netflix catalog with faceted search.