3 ms·
> Chapter 8, lines 1044-1047: Here the CMF appeals to a paper (Sadler, Sonnert, 2018) as if that paper gives evidence in favor of delaying calculus to college.
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
> Chapter 8, lines 1044-1047: Here the CMF appeals to a paper (Sadler, Sonnert, 2018) as if that paper gives evidence in favor of delaying calculus to college. But the paper’s message is opposite what the CMF is suggesting
The author takes issue with some other items but quotes this in what I think might be an approving way.
But, I took this as saying a) good coverage of the basics helps more than already covering the specific topic, and b) this supports shifting time from doing it twice to spending more time on fundamentals.
But, it's not saying X is bad, Y is good. It's suggesting trading one against the other to get the optimum mix based on what all students need (since some will never do it for the second time).
So simply saying X is good isn't really responding to the argument they are making. Neither is saying doing X and Y is better than either alone. It's like saying you can invest the same money in both Apple And Facebook stock and make even more money than investing it all in one of them.
They know X is good, but within a limited time resource they think a little less X and a little more Y would be better overall.
Maybe they're right, maybe they are wrong, but this quoted critique seems not even wrong, which is a bad place to be.