3 ms·
There are a few comments here questioning why it's really important to actually delete data. This is a serious issue for a few different reasons. If I believe
by ckinniburgh 15y ago
There are a few comments here questioning why it's really important to actually delete data. This is a serious issue for a few different reasons. If I believe that I've deleted something, then there should be no way for anyone to retrieve the information -- I no longer have to worry about security breaches at Facebook (internally or externally), Government warrants, or Facebook accidentally reinstating the information.
As for the idea that Facebook is to big to effectively delete information, that's unacceptable. If you're that big and you can't figure out a way of routinely deleting data then you need to find a way of collecting more data or making your data easier to delete, or not giving the user the 'delete' option. There are a number of alternate verbs which describe the process they are going through, none of which are as clear or commonly understood as 'delete', but which are more accurate. 'Hide' and 'make data invisible' come to mind.
I don't have as much of a problem with the saving of messages which others will also read, but on deleting a Facebook account, this could be handled more gracefully if the user wishes. This is a more difficult problem to solve, which would require Facebook itself to store messages with under the covers public key cryptography which sounds like the type of thing they wouldn't do.
- kisielk 15y agoFacebook could make data removable by users if they engineered their site to allow that. The problem is that they haven't, and it appears they've in fact done the opposite. We need data protection laws like this to put the onus on the service providers to make giving users control of their data a priority.
- Lukeas14 15y agoDeleting data in a complicated system is not at all a trivial task as data integrity can easily be impacted. So Facebook's excuse that they can't delete data at their scale is probably not just PR speak. For them there is no downside to keeping data besides a minority of their userbase complaining. Meanwhile the downside to deleting data is potentially huge and a mistake would be nonrecoverable. I wouldn't expect them to start deleting data anytime soon unless legally required to do so. I do agree that the verbage used on their site should more accurately reflect the actions occuring on their backend.
- kisielk 15y agoI agree that deleting data is probably difficult from a data integrity standpoint. However, unless being able to delete data is made a priority the situation is not going to improve. It's a more general problem and certainly not specific to Facebook but unless there is some motivator I don't think a whole lot of engineering effort is going to be put in to it by anyone. From a technology standpoint it seems it's more desirable to just keep throwing storage at the problem and spend time working on ways to store and manage even more data. Data is valuable after all, so the incentive is there to accumulate and process as much of it as possible. That's exactly why we need some form of external stimulus (eg: laws) to force people to work on the problem of how can we be getting rid of data when we need to without breaking everything.
- pilif 15y agoAlso for every user who complained that Facebook doesn't delete data, there will be thousands of users who complain that Facebook will not be able to restore accidentally deleted data.
- lemming 15y agoFor them there is no downside to keeping data besides a minority of their userbase complaining. Well, that and violatng the laws of some of the countries in which they operate.