4 ms·
Elon Musk’s antidepressant tweet puts people at risk
- smt88 5y agoFrom the bottom of my heart, I wish Elon Musk would shut up and go away. He is too arrogant and ignorant to be as powerful as he is. Lots of drugs have risks, but Wellbutrin literally saved my brother's life. I am more skeptical of psychiatric drugs than most people and bullish on psychedelics, but these issues should be up to a doctor. If some people safely benefit from a drug, it shouldn't be pulled off the market. Musk has no depth of understanding of any field except finance.
- incomingpain 5y agoAntidepressents have an efficacy of around 20-30%. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3736946/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3736946/ The majority of people do not benefit from taking them and there are some severe life changing side effects from taking them. Not to mention social and societal consequences. The therapeutic benefit is a calculation of efficacy vs side effects. The benefit of these drugs is in question. It's probably borderline at best, if it works for you great. So to make the conclusion that a tweet from musk, in context where he is nonstop joking, is going to put anyone at risk. That's absurd at best.
- leephillips 5y agoIt seems that Musk believes a few anecdotes are more informative than data. Would he say that Teslas are unsafe because of the occasional stories about fires and crashes, despite the data that shows they are exceedingly safe compared with other cars?
- dimensionc132 5y agoGod forbid someone has an opinion contrary to the drug manufacturer about a drug that has been shown to increase suicide risk and dangerous behaviour amongst people with depression. The horror. I guess someone should tell the Canadian Center for Suicide Prevention that they are wrong and to shut up https://www.suicideinfo.ca/resource/effects-of-bupropion-wellbutrin-on-suicidal-behavior-risk-taking-behavior-and-mood/ https://www.suicideinfo.ca/resource/effects-of-bupropion-wel...
- TurkishPoptart 5y agoExactly. Ever since the covid "vaccine" hysteria emerged, the media have drawn extremely rigid lines between "institutionally-approved medical views" and everything else that doesn't fit neatly into what Big Pharma and its governmental collaborators want to disseminate. And if you question that, you're "putting people at risk". No one should be reading WaPo anymore.
- smt88 5y agoThere is a wide chasm between "may cause suicidal ideation" and "should be entirely withdrawn from the market". Suicide is a difficult and sometimes rational decision. There really are people who, in their most lucid mind, would prefer to die. If antidepressants work to restore motivation, they may also restore someone's ability to take their own life. It's extremely complicated, and it should be up to a patient and their doctor. Lots of medical interventions can cause death, including breast implants. That's not, by itself, a reason to ban it.
- dimensionc132 5y agoOf course it is a complicated issue, no one denies that, however, if the Canadian Center for Suicide Prevention states in their findings; "There have been reports that state that Bupropion is the worst antidepressant for treating suicidal behaviors and may even play a part in increasing suicidal tendencies among users." and "These results would show that bupropion is a dangerous drug to use to treat depression." .... just maybe we should listen to people who know what they are talking about, instead of armchair psychiatrists.
- TurkishPoptart 5y ago>Health misinformation or unsound opinions that can be interpreted as medical advice shared by influential public figures, such as Musk, could have wide-reaching repercussions, said Steven Hoffman, a professor of global health, law and political science at York University in Toronto who has published research on how celebrities influence people’s health decisions. Oh no! Someone said something bad about a pharmaceutical product! This is extremely dangerous to our democracy! /s Seriously, I don't get why some comments on Twitter "put people at risk". This is rather disreputable of the WaPo, but par for the course to cheerlead for greater censorship of "misinformation", which to me appears to be the angle of this article. I do not want greater machinations of the state empowered to police peoples' opinions and shitposting. I would love to see evidence that this puts people "at risk".