3 ms·
There has never been a leak like this in the court’s history; and the way the court works is that an opinion is not an opinion of the court until the moment it
by SllX 5y ago
There has never been a leak like this in the court’s history; and the way the court works is that an opinion is not an opinion of the court until the moment it is handed down. This is a first draft from February while the court is still in its deliberative process and it has the potential to undermine the trust between Justices and between Justices and their staff not because of the contents of the draft—each and every Justice already had access to it—but because a leak happened at all and it was a politically motivated leak.
So yeah, this matters, and so does the state of the court’s integrity not because of what the general public thinks, but because if the court is to function at all, the court itself needs to believe in its own integrity.
- tomjen3 5y agoYou have not really given any arguments. Please tell me why this should not have been routinely published. I am aware that this is not the finished product, but I think it is clear to everyone that it is not.