3 ms·
I don't think "precedent" works the way for first sentence seems to think it does. The final decision will be precedent; drafts are not. And, "the majority be
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
I don't think "precedent" works the way for first sentence seems to think it does. The final decision will be precedent; drafts are not.
And, "the majority believes that Roe is flawed" is interesting information, but it also is not any kind of precedent. Decisions are going to depend on the details of the case before the court.
- Maursault 5y agoPrecedent occurs when a decision is challenged and upheld. If Roe is struck down, that will not be precedent, but overturning precedent, since Row was challenged and upheld in Casey. For a decision overturning Roe to become precedent, it would need to survive at least one future challenge.