3 ms·
I think the root problem is not income. People don't inherently need pieces of paper with numbers and dead faces printed on them. Monetary income is simply the
by ryandrake 5y ago
I think the root problem is not income. People don't inherently need pieces of paper with numbers and dead faces printed on them. Monetary income is simply the only way our primitive society has so far figured out how to provide for what people really need: Things like food, clothing, shelter, safety, autonomy, freedom, achieving their potential...basically everything up and down Maslow's hierarchy. You currently need monetary income to get these, but what if that wasn't so? How do we get to the point where everyone's life needs were simply met by default, and not dependent on their going off and working for these artificial money-points? We could, as a society, simply consider these needs to be rights, provide them to everyone, and skip the whole conversion to-and-from money. Let work and money be the "edge case" optional way for that motivated 1% of us to go out and get luxuries or privileges. It's not like we can't do this. We don't lack the technology, automation, mechanization... There is so much surplus economic value sloshing around that is simply captured and hoarded by the top 0.1%. We simply lack the political will to spread it around, and our existing winner-take-all power structures fiercely oppose anything like this utopia.
Everybody is entitled to and receives subsistence food--but if you want a tasty steak, go work for a few bucks to get it. We can do this! It is not beyond our capability! We have so much food it goes to waste, surely everyone can be fed if there was political will. Everyone is entitled to and receives a home--but if you want a nice lake house, go work for it. We can do this too! There's no shortage of homes. The existing power structures just don't want it, and the rest of us are powerless to change their minds.
- dredmorbius 5y agoSo ... you haven't actually described what condition you're discussing, and if that's poverty, precarity, homelessness, inequality, ... One of the reasons I strongly suggest that as the first link on the chain. That said ... I suspect we agree on at least some bases. People don't want income in much the same sense that people don't want backups. Users of technological systems want restores. People want the ability to satisfy their needs. We live in a financialised society, in which for the majority of people, the means to the necessities of life (food, clothing, shelter --- you'll find these in Plato's Republic, in Mencius's writings, in Smith, in Marx, in Maslow) is through payment-based transactions. As opposed to self-sufficiency (at best rare in virtually all human history, far more likely nonexistant), tribal provision, socially-recognised entitlements, etc. There are people for whom this simply does not work. The very young, the very old, the phyisically ill, the mentally ill, addicts. Also those oppressed or excluded from societies. The idea that the market serves all is ... curiously unsupported. The "society of abundance" concept is one I'm familiar with. I have issues with that as well --- we have not entirely solved the problem of production, though I'd also argue that that problem is in many ways not what it's presented to be. There is necessary work which is unappealing and often pushed off to those least able to avoid it. And there's much that's unhealthy about even some of the best and most desired jobs (see this bit on burnout from two days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31248787 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31248787 ... itself a frequent HN topic, with 1,322 submissions found: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=burnout&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...). My view is that there's probably a multi-factor approach that will be required: - Some form of income floor, established through a healthy union or labour movement, through a government employer of last resort, and/or a statutory minimum wage. These might be estabished nationwide, or within more regional markets. That last could be a national standard using localised price indices. - Some major form of housing reform. The notion of a housing supplier of last resort occurred to me some time ago. There is the notion of a Georgian land value tax. Major reforms to evictions should also be part of this. - Other areas of reform would include healthcare (still a mess within the US); mental health; reform to the police, courts, and penal systems; education; rights for workers, renters, women, underprivileged minorities, and others; and addressing systemic inequality. That's just scratching the surface. - All of this in a context in which the political and media systems are extraordinarily dysfunctional. (How individual readers interpret this will be ... interesting.) - And where there are a growing set of pressing global existential risks, most endogenous to humans --- we are our own greatest threat, rather than facing external threats, at present.