3 ms·
Overruling a case isn’t an all-or-nothing thing. Upholding Mississippi’s 15-week ban would simply require the Court to acknowledge that Roe’s protection of elec
by rayiner 5y ago
Overruling a case isn’t an all-or-nothing thing. Upholding Mississippi’s 15-week ban would simply require the Court to acknowledge that Roe’s protection of elective second trimester abortions turned out to be an error that continues to defy international norms and attract public opposition.
Overruling that part of Roe doesn’t require a meandering rant about abortion rights writ large.
- ss108 5y agoInternational norms?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Buge 5y agoAccording to [1], in 1973, Roe v. Wade said abortion is legal US-wide at 27/28 weeks and earlier, then in 1992, Planned Parenthood v. Casey said abortion is legal US-wide at 22/23/24 weeks and earlier. I'm not exactly sure whether the ages are inclusive or exclusive or how rounding/truncating works with the ages, which is why I made them fuzzy with the slashes. According to [2], there are 203 countries listed. I'll look at "on request" abortions. * North Korea is marked "unclear". * 6 allow abortion at 23 weeks (24 weeks is also an identical list): China, Colombia, Netherlands, Singapore, South Korea, South Ossetia * 2 additional allow abortion at 22 weeks: Iceland, Vietnam * 191 ban abortion at 22 weeks. * Australia ranges from completely prohibited to no limit, depending on region. * Canada ranges from 12 weeks and 6 days to 24 weeks and 6 days depending on region. * United states ranges from (ignoring the recent laws that prompted the ongoing cases) 20 weeks to no limit depending on region. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roe_v._Wade#Planned_Parenthood_v._Casey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roe_v._Wade#Planned_Parenthood... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_law#Independent_countries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_law#Independent_count...
- ss108 5y agoInteresting, thanks. I feel like nobody brings up other countries when it comes to abortion, but the context seems pretty helpful (as it is for most issues, I suppose). Esp since, looking at Australia and Canada, people get on and tolerate internal divergences, and maybe we should too. I suppose is it's because they accept that their federalism is much less centralized than ours.
- js2 5y agoMen arguing over women's wombs. Love it. So this doesn't paint a complete picture. It turns out that 93% of abortions in the U.S. happen at <= 13 weeks gestation: Among the 43 areas that reported gestational age at the time of abortion for 2019, 79.3% of abortions were performed at ≤9 weeks’ gestation, and nearly all (92.7%) were performed at ≤13 weeks’ gestation (Table 10). https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/ss/ss7009a1.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/ss/ss7009a1.htm So it's not like we're a country of monsters despite what's technically allowed by Roe. Now I want you to imagine for a moment what's happening in the life of a woman who chooses to have an abortion well into her pregnancy, likely after quickening when she can feel movement. Well it turns out you can't, because every case will be different. And I don't trust the state to insert itself into that decision. But I'll bet every one of these women has a story to tell and that it's heartbreaking, and that we don't make those women's lives better by forcing them to carry to term. Data from the Turnaway Study has resulted in the publication of more than 50 peer-reviewed studies, and the answer to nearly all the questions asked, said Foster, is that the women who got abortions fared better in respect to economics and health, including their mental health, compared with those who did not have abortions. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/01/21/1074605184/abortion-roe-v-wade-supreme-court https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/01/21/1074605... So that's my first point, but I acknowledged some will disagree. Now, Mississippi's law is to limit abortions to 15 weeks, so you may think it's a reasonable compromise. But with Roe overturned, it will not stop there. It's only a matter of time till some states ban abortion entirely. Some already have: https://www.guttmacher.org/state-policy/explore/state-policies-later-abortions https://www.guttmacher.org/state-policy/explore/state-polici... Anti-choicers will push for restrictions at the Federal level. They'll try to ban pharmaceutical abortion pills through the mail. They'll try to prevent women from traveling out of state. https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2022/05/02/abortion-ban-roe-supreme-court-mississippi/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2022/05/02/abortion-ba... https://khn.org/news/article/texas-medication-abortion-criminal-penalties/ https://khn.org/news/article/texas-medication-abortion-crimi... https://www.wbur.org/onpoint/2022/03/24/inside-missouris-push-to-ban-out-of-state-abortions https://www.wbur.org/onpoint/2022/03/24/inside-missouris-pus... Finally, outlawing abortions won't stop abortions. Never has and never will. What it will do is to punish poor women who don't have the means to travel to where abortion is legal. This is already the case under Roe, and w/o Roe it will be worse. So sure, Roe may have been poorly reasoned. Perhaps a decision based on equal protection instead of privacy would have been better. But it's what we have, and given the virtual impossibility of amending the constitution, it's the only way we can have a Federal standard. And no, I don't think handing it over to the states is workable, any more than it was workable to allow the states to decide segregation, voting rights, contraception, or interracial and gay marriage. Women are entitled to equal protection under the law, and that includes deciding whether to carry a baby to term. Overturning Roe is a travesty. Disclosure: I'm a guy.
- olsonjeffery 5y agoAbortion: one of the few times an american conservative will speak approvingly of “international norms”.
- rayiner 5y agoConservatives would assert that the Constitution says what it says and means what it was intended to mean, and that what the EU does,[1] or what the polls say,[2] don't matter. But given that nobody seriously argues that Roe has a foundation in the text or original intent of the Constitution, it's certainly fair for them to point out that Roe can't be defended by saying, as liberals usually do, that we have a "Living Constitution" that incorporates "evolving social norms." Because what the EU does and what the polls say are certainly evidence of what those "evolving social norms are." Roe raises the question of "where exactly do those 'evolving social norms' come from anyway?" And I suspect the honest answer is "the opinions of highly educated lawyers." [1] Just two EU countries, comprising 6% of the EU population, allow elective abortions after 14 weeks: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1268439/legal-abortion-time-frames-in-europe/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1268439/legal-abortion-t... [2] 65% of Americans think abortion should generally be illegal after the first trimester: https://apnews.com/article/only-on-ap-us-supreme-court-abortion-religion-health-2c569aa7934233af8e00bef4520a8fa8 https://apnews.com/article/only-on-ap-us-supreme-court-abort...
- random314 5y agoAnd completely forget international norms for health care :)