3 ms·
I'll echo a comment I wrote downstream: If you're making your home smarter, don't buy anything other than Zigbee (or Z-wave, but I haven't used that). It's an o
by stavros 5y ago
I'll echo a comment I wrote downstream: If you're making your home smarter, don't buy anything other than Zigbee (or Z-wave, but I haven't used that). It's an open protocol, which means any device that supports it (and they're a lot) will work with every other device.
They also work without the internet, they can pair with each other (so they work without a hub), the protocol is simple, mains-powered devices are usually repeaters as well, a coin cell battery lasts forever, etc etc. I'm never buying a wifi-based smart home device again.
Beware: IKEA says they support Zigbee but they don't work well.
- JamesSwift 5y agoIts not all peaches in Zigbee land. I'm troubleshooting issues with an Aqara temperature sensor as we speak. Aqara has plenty of "known" issues regarding Zigbee compatibility [1]. The unfortunate bit is that their devices are the best I've seen in terms of price/form-factor. [1] - https://community.hubitat.com/t/xiaomi-aqara-devices-pairing-keeping-them-connected/623 https://community.hubitat.com/t/xiaomi-aqara-devices-pairing...
- stavros 5y agoAh, that sucks :( I have those sensors and work fine, but I don't use a repeater... Too bad that compatibility isn't great.
- JamesSwift 5y agoRepeaters and a need for repeaters is a whole other can of worms for Zigbee. I've had to purchase and deliberately place some repeaters to get better coverage across the house, or else I end up with unreachable devices. And because of how the mesh works, you might have to reset devices to try and coax the mesh to rebuild if you move anything around. It's overall been a much more buggy setup than my wifi subnetwork.
- causi 5y agoIKEA says they support Zigbee but they don't work well Aqara has plenty of "known" issues regarding Zigbee compatibility any device that supports it (and they're a lot) will work with every other device You sure about that?
- stavros 5y agoYes, that's why I make a distinction between "supports it" and "says it supports it".
- Shish2k 5y agoFunnily enough I have ~40 smart devices in my home, around 30 IKEA and 10 Aqara, controlled by Home Asssistant on a raspberry pi with a ZZH USB stick — aside from some initial fiddliness where the aquaria devices would pick a random peer to connect to instead of a peer with good signal, it’s all working pretty great :D