3 ms·
Every vision of blockchain-centered future society that I have encountered so far in a nutshell implies that trust between fellow humans is inherently bad, and
by strogonoff 5y ago
Every vision of blockchain-centered future society that I have encountered so far in a nutshell implies that trust between fellow humans is inherently bad, and tries to eliminate it as much as possible.
I’ve met blockchain maximalists who passionately painted their vision of a future where you inherit some karma from your ancestors, increment or decrement it with every action you do in your life, and pass it on to your descendants.
They seem like smart and successful people, and their passion seems genuine. However, I feel like they have made some fundamentally incompatible assumption somewhere early in their thinking process. I can never understand how could anyone see removal of trust as a feature, and their vision intuitively strikes me as incredibly dystopian.
My personal take is that this all is an elaborate workaround for the fact that there are malicious actors (due to whatever reason, but mostly probably upbringing-related mental health issues and emotional/financial insecurities)—addressing that root cause will render such symptomatic treatments irrelevant; while enacting these treatments without addressing the root cause will result in much suffering.
- mjburgess 5y ago"trust" as an issue between machines on a network is ideally solved in a trustless way. The issue is that these tech-utopians havent understood that this is really a pun on the word "trust", and our social issues are in a sense, precisely the opposite.
- soco 5y agoEven the blockchain world needs blind trust in its inputs - oracles or humans. Any society is by definition formalized trust and a blockchain society is no exception, just moves the trust in some other corners. And anyway when I hear about the blockchain goal to remove the need for "unreliable trust" I remember the hawala money transfers which are the very embodiment of a system based on human trust, the complete antithesis to the blockchain premises AND which works just fine in the real life.