3 ms·
Talking to your opponent's viewpoint isn't being a Devil's advocate and you can't steelman a viewpoint that doesn't exist. Devil's advocate is about inventing a
by zamadatix 5y ago
Talking to your opponent's viewpoint isn't being a Devil's advocate and you can't steelman a viewpoint that doesn't exist. Devil's advocate is about inventing an opposing viewpoint when none exists to allow for debate to strengthen the case of the held viewpoint. Steelmanning is about solidifying the opposing viewpoint instead of minor errors specific to the original formulation of the opposing viewpoint allowing for a stronger defence of the held viewpoint.
I'd agree steelmanning used to be considered standard part of discussion but its breakout seems unrelated to reinventing Devil's advocate and more about reinventing that missing piece of discussion which doesn't usually occur in online debate. Regardless what steelmanning is or isn't that part of discussion was never supposed to be referred to as playing Devil's advocate.